Ian Welsh

The horizon is not so far as we can see, but as far as we can imagine

Obama Bypassed the A-List Rather Than Co-Opting It

I love me some Anglachel, in many respects.  In her review of Eric Boehlert’s book Bloggers on the Bus, she notes that it’s missing some important precursors of the blogosphere, such as the Daily Howler and Media Whores.  But she also goes on and on about how the Netroots was run by the Obama campaign and became part of the media circle, whose job it was to elect Obama.  Since Anglachel was and is a complete Clinton partisan, her objection isn’t to partisanship, it is to partisanship for Obama despite the fact that Clinton was better on a number of domestic issues (such as healthcare).

I was managing editor of the Agonist during the primaries, and managing editor of FDL after the primaries and during the campaign proper.  Here’s the deal: with a couple of exceptions (such as Americablog), the A-list was not primarily for Obama in the primaries.  As much as it was for anyone, its preference was John Edwards, though for various reasons it never fully got on board his campaign (something which displeased me at the time, and spare me the “he was cheating” amateur quarterbacking, since no one I knew believed it during the primary).

What Obama did wasn’t to manage the A-listers, he cut past the A-listers with direct outreach to their readers and captured their base from them.  The Netroots didn’t turn pro-Obama from the top down, it turned pro-Obama from the bottom up.  I saw this both at the Agonist and FDL.  I saw it other places.  Clinton was never that popular online, and when it became clear that Edwards wasn’t going to win, the majority of readers turned to Obama.

The A-listers did not lead on this.  As with the old joke about political leadership, they saw where the crowd was running, and they ran to the front of the pack and pretended to lead.  There were exceptions, such as MyDD, where Jerome Armstrong remained pro-Clinton.  And there were honorable cases of this.  Jane Hamsher at FDL was very clear, for example, that FDL would support whoever the Democratic nominee was.  If it had been Clinton or Edwards or Kucinich, I can guarantee FDL would have supported that person.  Hard.  I think the same is true of most other A-listers though there’s no question that some made threats of not supporting Clinton.  The majority of such articles however, however, were written not by A-listers themselves, but diarists.

In Democratic party politics you have power if you can either deliver an identifiable block of voters, or if you can deliver money. Barack Obama bypassed the blogs on both counts, getting the voters and the money without needing the Netroots.  If the Lieberman primary was a bow shot across the establishment by the Netroots, the presidential election of 2008 was a demonstration of the limits of Netroots power and of the fact that with enough money and smart operatives the A-listers were gatekeepers who could be bypassed.

That doesn’t mean that Anglachel isn’t partially correct that the A-list has been partially co-opted.  Parts of it have, without question.  But to think that the A-list has become part of the Village is incorrect.  The Village doesn’t need the A-list, and knows it.  Barack Obama proved it.

On Mothers Day: Caging a Nightingale

It being mother’s day, and the entire world conspiring to tell me about it, over and over again, I’ve been thinking a bit about my mum.  She died 3 years ago of cancer.  I spent her last two weeks by her bed, and she died the night I told her that everyone had come and that it was ok for her to die.  By that point she couldn’t speak, and while she didn’t seem to be in much pain, she certainly wasn’t enjoying what was left of her life.

She had lived her life for other people—for me, and for her husband.  I don’t know any of her close friends who didn’t think she should have gotten a divorce when I was a young kid, but she didn’t.  At that time I’m pretty sure it was because she was threatened with losing me.

But really, the woman she was when I was young died when I was 13.  I remember it well.  My father had gotten a job with the UN, in Bangladesh.  My mother didn’t want to go.  As far as my father was concerned, where the husband went the wife went.

In Canada she had a job, as the secretary to the woman who ran the Coquitlam library system.  It was the most senior secretarial position in the organization and quite responsible.  In her early forties, she looked ten years younger, fit and slim, with dark black hair.  She walked everywhere, regularly walking 30 or 40 blocks a day, and while I think it’s safe to say she wasn’t happy, she had a life with some happiness in it.

She went with my father to Bangladesh.  I went to boarding school in Vancouver.  4 months later I visited my parents, for Christmas, in Bangladesh.    She had no job, no life outside the house.  She had loved children, and they loved her, but now she had no child to look after, neither me nor our cousins.  Her life was completely her husband’s. My mother had put on 40 pounds, her hair was half gray and her eyes were dull.

She had been broken.  The woman she was had died.  Like a man who cages a nightingale in his fist, by not letting it have any freedom, my father had killed what he loved.  I don’t know if he ever even realized it, or if he did, if he cared, or if the pleasure of imposing his will made up for it.

The women in my family usually make it to their late 80s and my father was 10 years older than my mother and not in good health.  So I always assumed she’d have a good 20 years free.  She didn’t.

But she died free.

About 3 weeks before she died, when she knew she had cancer but assumed she had 8 months to a year left, we talked.  She told me that she had decided to move out, and that she would never live with him again.  I was never so happy for her.

A few days later she collapsed, and never walked again.  Then she died.

But she died free.

My wish to you and for myself, this mother’s day then, is this.

Don’t die free.

Live free.

Long Term Treasury Rates Rise: Why?

Badtux lists three possible reasons:

1) Inflation expectations are setting in, which is good, because it will force folks to take money out of the mattress and start lending it or otherwise making use of it.  (If a dollar in 5 years will be worth less than a dollar today, you should either spend it or invest it in something which lets it at least keep its value.)

2) Deflation means there isn’t enough money to buy treasuries because people are hiding it in their matresses or overseas.

3) The deficit’s so big it’s eating up all the money, and therefore higher interest rates are necessary.

Commenter Jay adds a fourth, the Chinese have made decisions which have reduced the demand for treasuries.

I’ll add a fifth: foreign investors fear that the dollar is overvalued and will decline.  Any decline in the dollar, if you need your money in another currency eventually, is a loss.  When interest rates are very low, it wouldn’t take much of a decline for you to fall into a loss position, and the entire point of buying treasuries is safety.

Which is it?  Badtux thinks some of 1 and 2, with a bit of 3.  I don’t see why not some of all 5.  Unlike Badtux, who thinks that if is the case the Fed should just buy more treasuries, I’m less sure that’s the correct response, because all this printing money (which is what that amounts to) is making me really twitchy.

Why?  Because I think that all this money is

a) going to have to be paid back eventually, and that paying it back is going to depress standards of livings for much longer than people think, because I don’t believe that this money has led to any realy likelihood of significant real increases in real world (as opposed to fantasy financial world) productivity.

b) I do think there’s a real possibility of inflation, and while as Badtux notes, a little inflation is a good thing, it’s not clear to me that it’ll be contained.  Of course, if it isn’t contained, becomes less of a problem, since the debts will be inflated away, but serious inflation isn’t something to be laughed at, less because of the economic consequences (which are bad enough) than because of the political consequences (which are almost always a very rightward political swing.)

For the record, I’m sticking to my prediction of riptide inflation – some sectors deflating (such as wages, which is now evident but which was obvious months ago) and others inflating (like oil).

In any case, go read Badtux’s article, he’s got more good stuff there.

Central Bank Inflation Targeting Wasn’t Quite the Problem

Martin Wolf, one of the best economics commenters, notes that the widespread idea that central banks, over the past 30 years, had found the holy grail of policy in inflation targeting, was clearly wrong.  That’s good as far as it goes, and he’s right.  But it’s worth taking farther—the problems with inflation targeting included the definition of inflation, the inflation target and the uncontrolled flow of money

Inflation as measured during this period did not take into account asset bubbles.  Wolf almost notices this, when he notes that the Fed didn’t see it as its job to stop asset bubbles.  But he doesn’t go quite far enough: asset price increases are a type of inflation.  If it costs more to buy a dollar of future income, a house, or a share in a company, that’s inflation.  To manage inflation properly, as a central bank, requires first to know what inflation is, and that means adding asset inflation into an inflation index.  This would be the opposite of the current “core inflation” index, which is non-asset inflation minus food and energy prices, ostensibly to remove volatility (which is not the way to remove volatility, the way to remove volatility is to use a moving average.)  Of course, in the real world, increases in fuel prices and energy prices are, well, inflation.  Add in credit price increases as well, and you’d have a measure which actually measures inflation.  Target that, and you’d be targeting something real.

The second issue is simpler, the inflation target was too low.  It seems like inflation being low is nothing but good, but in fact the lower it is, the more sectors of the economy are actually in deflation at any given time.  If inflation is 5% and consumer goods, say, are 4% less than that, they aren’t in deflation.  If inflation is at 3% and consumer goods are at 4% less, they’re at -1% and are deflating. As the last little while (and the Great Depression) have taught us, deflation is not a good thing, and yet for a long time large parts of the economy have been in and out of deflation fairly constantly.  In addition, a higher rate of inflation discounts past economic activity, which isn’t an entirely bad thing, as it means people have to be agressive with their money.  In a world where fraud and financial speculation wasn’t the best way to make returns, that is a good thing.  (In our world, perhaps not, admittedly.)

Finally, open financial flows turn bank policies into something of a joke.  As Wolf himself notes, foreign central bank independence from the Fed was largely chimerical: other central banks had to lower interest rates along with the Fed, and if they didn’t, then hot money would pour in from the US, or for that matter, from Japan, which was running its interest at zero or near zero for much of the past 20 years.

As a result, the effective interest rate was whatever the lowest interest rate of a large credible central bank with relatively stable currency was.  (If you’re borrowing from a country with an unstable currency, and the currency appreciates suddenly, your apparent low interest rate can turn into a trap which costs you greatly.)

This meant that even if central banks wanted money to be expensive, for those people and corprorations able to borrow from foreign sources, it wasn’t, and the asset bubbles, inflation and so on which came from that came even if the bank was trying to be conservative.  Real independent monetary policy is greatly damaged by free money flows between countries, which is even before you get to its damaging effect on real free trade and comparative advantage.

And old management maxim is that you get what you measure.  Central banks weren’t measuring all inflation, and so they weren’t managing asset inflation, which is one main reason we got asset bubbles.  Add to that that even where they were targetting inflation, they were targetting it at too low a level and that international money flows made it difficult to run an independent bank policy even in countries which might have wanted to, and you had a very flawed central banking system in virtually every country in the world.

So it’s not clear to me that inflation targetting is necessarily a bad policy.  It seems more likely that it might have been a good policy, implemented in a very bad way.  It disciplined the small actors in the economy, small businesses and ordinary workers—restricting their wages and their goods inflation, while allowing rampant inflation in securities and real-estate and (in the 90s) stocks.

The people who weren’t disciplined, then, drove a truck through the hole created and caused a disaster.  The lesson isn’t “we shouldn’t target inflation”, the lesson is “we need to target all inflation” not just inflation which effects some people.

Iraq’s Papered Over Problems Flare Up As the Iraqi Endgame Starts

Image by a62a68

Image by a62a68

The “surge” worked, mainly, not because of more troops, but because of more money and weapons.  The Sunnis needed money and guns to fight their insurgency.   They got those, in part, from Al-Q’aeda in Iraq, but by the time of the surge AQ had overstepped itself and tried to get control.  It started assassinating Sunni leaders and it engaged in very indiscriminate killing, which the Sunnis didn’t like. along with engaging in some violations of the norms of war as the Sunnis saw it.

Into this stepped in the US and says “we can give you money and weapons, and all you have to do is take out the AQ people who are trying to get control of you by assassinating your leaders”.  This then was the “Awakening” – guns and money for dealing with AQ and for peace afterwards.

Since the endgame in Iraq was about who would control Iraq after the US left, which was indicated by the fact that Iraqi government forces were under heavier attack than the Americans (who were attacked just enough to keep the cost high), the Sunnis said “sure.”  By accepting the money and arms they got to build up to be in a better position when the Americans left—either for negotiation, or for war.

But the Shia run central government is aware of this, and in the past few months they’ve started arresting and assassinating Sunni leaders, in preparation for when the Americans leave.  Remember, the Sunni government forces aren’t that impressive.  Their last independent major operation was in Basra against the Sadrists, and until American forces intervened and Iranians played diplomat, they were losing.

So Maliki is trying to get his licks in and weaken or break the Sunnis before the Americans leave.

As a result you’re seeing a spike in attacks, because the Sunni Awakening leaders don’t want to be arrested or killed, strangely enough.  You aren’t seeing all out warfare yet, because the Sunnis know the US will step in, since the US is helping Maliki with his crackdown, and the Sunnis want to save their forces for the real showdown: over who controls Iraq after the US leaves, or perhaps more accurately, who gets how much of the oil revenues.

Iraq is not stable.  The problems in Iraq were papered over with money.  But now that the money is going away, and Maliki is violating the terms of the American brokered truce, the papered over problems are re-emerging.

Endnote: In addition to the Awakening, the Sadrists standing down, the completion of ethnic cleansing in Baghdad, Iranian intervention, and the British withdrawal from Basra all contributed.  But in terms of the Sunnis, money and guns for peace was the primary consideration.

The FDIC Is Levying Money From Banks To Spend: Not For “Confidence”

Brian Angliss notes that the FDIC is levying a huge 20 cent per 100 dollars on deposit at the bank fee. He notes that the largest banks, having received lots of TARP money, will be able to pay that off using their taxpayer money, while smaller banks will get hammered and may either go under or be forced to cut back on jobs, branches and so on.

But Brian seems to take the FDIC’s announcement that they are doing this to improve confidence at face value.  I think, rather, the FDIC has made this sudden cash grab for a different reason: it needs the money for Geithners plan to buy up toxic assets.

Remember that the FDIC is providing most of the cash of the first part of the plan, up to 850 billion dollars worth of it.  That’s a lot of money.  Of course, the levy won’t raise that much, but it can and will be leveraged to buy up the toxic assets.  So what is taken away from the banks will be given back, in the form of removing toxic assets at overvalued prices.

The question though, is which banks will benefit. By and large, so far, the largest banks have received the majority of help from the Feds.  If assets are not proportionally bought from all the banks (and they won’t be) this could well lead to exactly what Brian fears—money being taken from small banks disproportionately, which will damage them and cause many to fail.

One Reason Why Some Men Treat Women So Badly

One my friends has been wondering why some men treat women so badly, including battery, rape and murder and seem to feel that their actions are totally justified and natural.

There’s no simple answer, I suspect, but I think one part of it is hinted at by this:

Young children think about gender in the same way they think about species of animals. They believe, for example, that a boy’s preference for football is innate, as is a girl’s preference for dolls, just as cats’ behavior is innately different from dogs’…

…The study’s findings confirm prior research, which has shown that adults and children alike think different species have deep biological differences, for example, that innate differences cause dogs to behave differently from cats. This study also found that it’s not until children are at least 10 that they treat gender and species concepts as distinct from one another, as adults do. At that age, they also understand that environment plays a role in gender-related behaviors.

I think a lot of people never really get over this.  In the same way that for most of history and indeed today in many places stranger is the equivalent of alien or enemy, to many men (and women, but with less devestating effects) the other gender isn’t even really human.  As such, just as with strangers in traditional societies, whatever is done to them is moral, because they aren’t even of the same species.  There is no real sense of connection, of empathy shared on commonality.

The only way to break through this is usually to say “what if it were your daughter/mother/sister, but men often put those women into a special category and don’t generalize.

I should add that female contempt for men, is often palpable, and I’ve heard many women use the word man in a way that indicates they consider the entire gender beneath contempt, and men innately weak (which is amusing, because many men think the same of woman.)  Of course, very few women use that contempt as an excuse for battering, raping and killing men.

The Chrysler Bankruptcy May Not Be As Smooth As Hoped

Chrysler went into bankruptcy because creditors wouldn’t agree to be wiped out.  They may believe that they will do better in front of a bankruptcy court, or some of them may have credit default swaps (CDSs) and have wanted Chrysler to go under so they would be paid off at full dollar (which points out another problem with CDSs, that they make bondholders more willing to force companies into bankruptcy.)

The government’s plan is to have a quick 30 to 60 day bankruptcy, shed the debts, and come out of it with the United Auto Workers owning 55%, the US government 8%, the Canadian and Ontario sharing 2% and Fiat receiving 10% with the possibility of more.

But bankruptcy court is not a sure thing.  The bankruptcy judge will have discretion and there are laws to be followed.  It is by no means a sure thing that this plan will survive contact with the court.  The debt holders will go to the judge and argue that they deserve to own much more Chrysler or that it should be broken up and that their claims take precedence.

I don’t know if they’ll succeed.  Certainly the government will put all their weight behind the current plan.

The next question, then, is GM, where the same calculation is playing out: a lot of debt holders think that they can do better in bankruptcy than through the government plan.  How the bankruptcy judge starts ruling in the first days of Chrysler’s bankruptcy will have a lot to do with whether GM debt-holders crumble.  If the judge seems ready to ram through the government plan, then GM probably won’t go bankrupt.  If he isn’t, it probably will.  Assuming of course that enough debt-holders don’t have CDSs covering their GM debt.  If they do, well, it’s in their interest to crash the company no matter what.

Page 524 of 532

Powered by WordPress & Theme by Anders Norén