The horizon is not so far as we can see, but as far as we can imagine

Category: Economics Page 1 of 101

If Our Government Makes Dollars, What Is the ‘National Debt’?

Thomas Neuburger and I recently agreed that either of us could post the full contents of the other’s posts if we so desired. The below is written by Thomas and a truly beautiful piece of work that I wanted everyone to read. I’ll have commentary on it at a later date, but I think most of it speaks for itself.

By Thomas Neuburger

“[T]he government … ought to be so constituted as to protect the minority of the opulent against the majority.”
—James Madison, June 26, 1787

“[A positive interest rate policy is] basic income for those who already have money.”
—Warren Mosler, here

This is Part 5 of a brief series on money. We started it here, with a look at what dollars are. There we uncovered the most basic fact about dollars, obvious yet never ever acknowledged:

  • You can’t create dollars. Only the government does that.

Everything else in this series proceeds from that fact. If you memorize that, you’ll understand everything. Our story so far:

And this, Part 5, addresses the question, “If our government makes dollars from nothing, what’s the ‘national debt’?”

To answer we need to go back to Part 4, and its discussion of the voluntary requirement to sell Treasury bonds. You can read that discussion, but in short, our government has voluntarily tied its own hands. Though it can create dollars directly, and it can authorize (via Congress) to spend as much as it wants, the Treasury is forced to sell bonds to finance itself entirely by choice, by laws that can be repealed.

Please support this site by sharing our work. Thanks!

Share

First Principles First

To begin, consider these points:

  • The source of all U.S. dollars is ultimately the government.

There’s no other source. The Fed creates dollars because the government says it can. Banks create dollars by lending beyond their reserves — lending cash they don’t have — because the government says it can. The government’s always in charge of dollar creation.

  • Therefore, the government has no inherent need to borrow. Do airlines need to borrow “airline miles” to give them away? Of course not; they make them. End of.
  • Each dollar spent by the government is a dollar in somebody’s pocket. No spending, no dollars.
  • The Treasury is financed with bonds only because that’s the law. If those laws were repealed, the Treasury could just create dollars and buy what it needs.
  • Treasury bonds are therefore a gift, offered to people with money. If you don’t have money, or not enough of it, you can’t buy government bonds. If you have money to spare, you can.

The ‘National Debt’

So what’s the “national debt”? It’s the sum of all Treasury bonds held outside the government. This includes bonds held by you, by mutual funds and the like, by banks and the Fed itself, and by foreign governments and their own central banks.

Thus:

  • The “national debt” is the market for U.S. Treasuries.
    • Because having a Treasuries market is voluntary, the “national debt” is really just an investment vehicle, a way to give money to people who already have money via interest payments.
    • The “national debt” is therefore not a debt, but a gift.

Subscribed

Why Have a Treasuries Market?

So why do we have it, this market for U.S. Treasuries?

First, think of the wealthy. The world of the rich needs a 100% guaranteed place to stash money, especially when the world seems unstable. The Treasuries market is that place.

Now think of the money supply. Dollars exist because government spends and because banks are permitted to lend money they don’t have. So if there’s too much money around, the government takes some of it back, reducing the supply.

How? Here’s where it gets interesting. Government has two ways of taking money out of the economy. The first is through federal taxes. Everyone is taxed, but the system is so skewed that the rich avoid being taxed almost entirely.

Between 2014 and 2018, Elon Musk’s wealth grew by $13.9 billion, yet he paid only $455 million in federal income taxes, resulting in an actual tax rate of about 3.27% (ProPublica, 2021). In contrast, the average American family’s effective federal income tax rate was 13.3% in 2018 (Tax Foundation, 2021). This stark difference highlights how the current tax system enables wealth accumulation without proportionate tax contributions. [emphasis mine]

And from ProPublica:

Some years billionaires pay no federal income taxes: Jeff Bezos paid zero in 2007 and 2011, Elon Musk paid zero in 2018, Michael Bloomberg paid zero several times in “recent years”, and George Soros paid zero three years in a row.

So how does the government extract excess money from the rich? That’s the second way: It pays the rich to surrender its cash temporarily by offering the Treasuries market. Bonds bought means money retired, at least for a while.

Two ways to reduce the money supply, taxation and the Treasuries market. Thus another of the great imbalances in our system. When government wants to reduce the money supply it extracts unreimbursed and involuntary-given money from you via your taxes, and reimbursed and voluntary-given money from the wealthy via Treasury bonds.

Or, as Cory Doctorow puts it:

Taxes coercively reduce the purchasing power of the private sector (they’re a stick). T-bills do the same thing, but voluntarily (they’re the carrot).

So What If the Government Paid Off the ‘National Debt’?

The answer has to be clear from what you just read. If the “national debt” is the market for U.S. Treasuries, and the government…

  1. Repealed every law requiring the issuance of bonds, and
  2. Paid off all Treasury bonds, bills and notes outstanding, and
  3. Never issued new ones — not ever, not once

…the U.S. Treasuries market would disappear. In whole, not in part.

Does anyone with money want that? You may not care, though if you have enough to invest in a Treasury fund, you’d be getting above 5%. But the super-rich definitely care. They need a place to stash cash when nothing seems safe, and our government is nothing if not a servant of wealth (see quotes above).

The national debt is the sum of all “deficit” spending expressed as the total of publicly-held Treasury bonds. If we paid off the “debt,” we’d be in a whole new world.

Americans Still Love Billionaires Too Much

We’re about 2 weeks into our annual fundraiser. We’ve raised about $8,955 out of a $14,500 goal from 69 people. This blog is free for everyone to read, and we’ve got about ten thousand visitors a month. Of those about 6K are regulars. 

The simplest truth of capitalism is that you get more of what you pay for. Money sends the message and resources required to do things. In most cases your power is tiny, one of millions, but this isn’t like that because the numbers and the need (to keep the blog and Ian running) are relatively small.

So if you value this blog, if it’s worth having around to you, please consider Subscribing or Donating.


There was a fair bit of good news during the election, but one vote which went very wrong was California’s vote on a one time wealth tax on billionaires, proposition. It failed 55% against, 45% for.

California’s a fairly “blue” state, but still, Americans won’t tax the rich.

And the simple truth is that nothing significant can be done to fix America as long as it’s an oligopoly: as long as the rich control government. There are some good signs, of course, billionaires spent a lot of money trying to stop the blue wave and failed. Millions were spent against progressive candidates like El-Sayed and failed.

But money is what gives oligarchs power: power to bribe, power to fund intellectuals and propagandists, power to control government for their own ends. As the famous Princeton oligarchy study detailed, the opinions of ordinary people have no effect on policy.

The bottom line is fairly simple: since elites don’t experience most of the shit parts of life in the US, they don’t care. Education sucks? So what, their kids go to private school. Healthcare sucks? So what, they can bypass the crap and get the best care. Security at airports and a crappy flight experince? They don’t go through the same security, since they fly on private jets.

Welfare keeps getting cut because they want the money for other priorities and they control most politicians. AI could steal everyone’s IP except a few groups with lawyers, same reason. Food prices don’t effect them, it could go up ten times, and it’d be a rounding error to the expenses.

In general, they certainly don’t want low prices, because high prices benefit them more than harm them. Cost of living? If you’re rich, it’s irrelevant.

The most fundamental rule of good societies is that people with power and wealth can’t be allowed to buy their way out of the experience of ordinary people. No private schools. No private jets. No private health care that is unaffordable to ordinary people. No wars that they or their children don’t fight in themselves.

As long as the rich have a lock on political power they will control the US and until a majority of people understand that and vote and act as if rich people are the enemy, life will keep getting worse. It’s that simple.

 

Bullshit Stats: Indian Poverty

So, India and Indian chuds are doing a victory round because supposedly Indian poverty has massively dropped to 2.6%. Supposedly 496 million Indians were lifted out of poverty.

What’s the poverty threshold? Making over $3/day. You are still poor, even in India, at $3 a day. As Cateleya says:

Poverty depends on where you draw the line At the $3 threshold, only 2.6% are poor. At the $4.20 threshold, 16.1% are poor.

And, for the record, at $4.20 a day you’re still in poverty.

Some other stats:

Yeah.


Folks, it’s my annual fundraiser. This fundraiser keeps the lights on. Everything here is free, there’s no ads, I don’t take sponsored posts and I don’t write pro-Israeli propaganda, even though I’ve been offered money (which I could really use) to sell my soul and betray my readers. If you can give, if it won’t cause you hardship, & you value this site and the writing here, please Subscribe or Donate. So far we’ve raised $8,780 from 68 people, meaning we’re a bit over half way to our goal.


Anyway, this is why I don’t trust stats I don’t investigate. There are stats that are somewhat accurate, for sure, but if you eyeball and number and you think it’s off, it probably is. CPI is bullshit in almost every country. Poverty and extreme poverty stats are almost all bullshit as well, except from China, which actually has lifted people out.

As for India, it’s a wreck. Modi’s policies have been terrible, starting with demonetization, when he took all large bills out of circulation to defeat corruption and hit the grey and black markets. Seemed like a good idea, but it empowers middlemen to take an electronic cut, and those markets were huge in India.

And, surprise, it didn’t make any real difference to corruption.

Further, AI is hitting offshoring hard, since companies are keen to replace employees, even cheap Indian speaking employees, with it. This is hurting all those Indian customer service centers, but also a lot of offshored programmers and so on. India went hard into being an outsourcing center, and unlike China mostly hasn’t used it to uplift their population as a whole, create a domestic market or build its own domestic industry meant for consumption in India. It’s a financialized, extremely corrupt state, with government full of criminals, authoritarian and ineffective.

I still see no reason to believe that India will be “the next China”. Yes, they have a lot of young people, but they don’t have much else going for them. Even without onrushing climate change I don’t think they’d make it, with global warming and onrushing water and rainfall issues, I see no hope. While India won’t be the first country hit hard by climate change (various Island states, Bangladesh, etc…) it’s going to be the first major country to be hit hard unless the Atlantic current flips sooner than expected (in which case Europe is beyond screwed._ I fully expect mass famines withing twenty years, and hundreds of millions dead.

I hope I’m wrong, but I see few signs that suggest otherwise.

Subscribe or Donate

US Spends Way More On R&D Than China

The difference is huge:

Europe’s share of global tech R&D has collapsed from 23% in 2005 to just 8% today, while the US has climbed to 62% and China has risen from near zero to 15%. South Korea now outspends Germany, France, the UK, and Italy combined in tech R&D. Yep, you read that right.

The funny thing is that China’s ahead in over 80% of techs, and has 8 of the top 10 research universities as measured by papers.

Tech:

It’s grim.

New research from the Australian Strategic Policy Institute (ASPI) shows that China is now leading the way in 57 out of the 64 technologies assessed by its Critical Technology Tracker, which has now been updated to cover the last 20 years.

But the point here is that America is spending four times as much as China, and China’s so far in the lead they’ve essentially lapped America. (Europe is irrelevant, the other tech leaders are Korea and Japan.)

 


It’s my annual fundraiser. This allows us to cover the changeover of hegemony from America to China, environmental collapse, internal US fascism, what a better society would look like, Gaza, AI, the coming stock market crash and various other issues. As of this writing we’ve raised about $5,120 out of a $14,500 goal, from 58 people. It’d be great if you can help out (please don’t donate if your financial situation is dire.) You can Subscribe or Donate here or contact me at admin-at-ianwelsh-dot-net if you need another way to donate (mail, usually. A lot of cash apps don’t work in Canada.)


It’s probably a bit tiresome for regular readers, but I bring this all up to emphasize a few points.

First: GDP means nothing. Nothing. Everything in the US is way more expensive, inefficient and unless it’s a luxury sector serving the wealthy, of low quality.

Second: there is NO possibility of the West catching up with China without reducing costs and increasing efficiency. It just can’t be done. That means health care, real-estate, food costs: practically everything.

Third, though not obvious in the above data, much of the efficiency comes from the fact that China has a massive ecosystem of tech firms, including huge clusters of small and middle sized businesses. You want to prototype in China, you can walk right into a factory in Shenzen and have it days to weeks. In the US it takes months or years.

Once you lose this ecosystem, and the US has lost much of theirs, getting it back is unbelievably hard. You’ve got to control costs, and so on, but it also takes decades of industrial policy. There’s no quick cure for what ails the West, too much is gone already, and that is compounded by the scarcity of rare resources and key manufacturing, like machine goods, basic electronics (including things like magnets) and so on.

And since the West sanctioned the hell out of China, they’re now returning the favor. Their sanctions on Japan are likely to destroy multiple market leading tech companies. US and European companies can’t get what they need for many advanced technologies. It’s… well, not hopeless, but pretty damn close.

AI is the last big US tech advance, and my bet is that China, with its open source models that are up to thirty times cheaper (and can run on local systems) are going to win that race where it matters: in adoption. It’s just safer to use Chinese models, which, at least so far, also tend to have a lot less usage restrictions.

If the West didn’t want this to happen we had to act decades ago. The tech lead ALWAYS goes to where the manufacturing floor is, that was true for Britain to America and it’s true for America to China.

But cheer up, America being weak is one reason why Iran can win. America’s weakness is the best hope for Palestinians, since without America, Israel is toast. And, as an added bonus, America has lots and lots of billionaires. That’s what American policy was meant to do, and it succeeded. Chinese policy was meant to lift hundreds of millions of people out of poverty and to make China strong, and it succeeded.

The West got what it wanted: impoverished weak workers and the richest rich the world has ever known

Don’t Talk Human Welfare With Elites, Talk Money (Hospital Edition)

Once a year I do a fundraiser. The blog has always been free to read. Nothing is behind a subscription wall. But the blog is also not viable without reader support. At most I’d keep it up and write an article or two a week. Donations allow us to cover the changeover of hegemony from America to China, environmental collapse, internal US fascism, what a better society would look like, Gaza, AI, the coming stock market crash and various other issues.

As of this writing we’ve raised about $4,120 out of a $14,500 goal, from 52 people. If you value what we do, please give (but also don’t donate if your financial situation is dire.) You can Subscribe or Donate here or contact me at admin-at-ianwelsh-dot-net if you need another way to donate (mail, usually. A lot of cash apps don’t work in Canada.)


Regular readers will know that I’ve spent years pushing for cleaning the air in hospitals and schools. Every time I do so some (censored) says “but it’ll cost a lot of money.”

Well, it looks like Canada might be moving towards this in hospitals. Why?

Roughly one in ten hospital inpatients acquires an infection during their stay. A patient who would have stayed one week may stay two or three. As a result, as many as one in five hospital beds can be occupied by someone who was infected in hospital. Those blocked beds back up emergency departments and delay care for everyone else.

“Allowing 10% of our patients to get infected is unsustainable,” said Hunt. “The cost is simply too high. Billions of dollars are spent on treatment, and many billions more are lost to the inefficiency of blocked beds.”

Each new hospital bed costs about $1 million to build – and another $500K to $1 million annually to staff and operate. Protecting a bed with upper-air UV costs about $5,000 initially and a few hundred dollars a year to maintain and operate.

Between 10,000 and 20,000 Canadian hospital beds are blocked on any given day, and CHAIR believes universal airborne protection could cut that number in half. The pilot is designed to test that hypothesis with measured data.

It’s only a two hospital trial for now, but still a good thing.

But they’re not doing the right thing because they care about people dying.

They’re not doing the right thing because they don’t want people to get infections which may cripple them.

They’re not doing the right thing because they don’t want people to suffer.

Oh no. It’s because sick people are expensive and they want to save money.

This is the universal issue in the West. Nothing is done unless you can make a money argument (and often even not then.)

Let’s be clear: it was always obvious that letting people get sick was more expensive than cleaning the air. Always. Letting people get disabled by long Covid is even more expensive (though much of the West is cutting support for disabled people, to try and make this less true.)

In Ontario, where I live, the Premier decided to get rid of safe drug injection sites. People argued with him, “people will die!” Stupid. That’s OK by him. But he gets a lot of heat for packed emergency rooms and he wants lower hospital costs so he can spend government money on his cronies (I could sky write this over the provincial legislature and not be sued, because his actions prove me right.) So the correct argument was “this will cost money and piss off voters.” That he might (might) have listened to.

But the problem is that in addition to our elites being greedy, they’re also stupid. Again, not treating air in hospitals (and schools) was obviously going to be more expensive than doing so.

The other issues are perceived opportunity cost and agency problems.

Back in the 90s an important book called “Natural Capitalism” came out. It’s still worth reading. Its basic thesis (well supported) was that there were a lot of environmentally friendly things business could do that would cut costs for businesses massively.

Didn’t happen. Even when they would pitch companies with we can reduce your energy/building/whatever by 30%, most businesses wouldn’t go for it. After all executives could spend that money instead to juice quarterly returns, which would juice the stock price, which would make their stock options and grants worth more. Doesn’t matter how much you could save by making your buildings more energy efficient: that doesn’t immediately drop money into the pockets of executives.

So if you want an elite to do something, remember, the question is always “what’s in it for the elite?” No other reason has any weight at all, you might as well be trying to convince Trump that gilding is tacky.

We’re ruled (in the West) by psychopaths. Nothing that wouldn’t convince a psychopath will convince a member of the Western elites to do anything, talking about “do it because it’s good” is like trying to convince the Devil that he should promote kindness, compassion, charity and peace.

SUBSCRIBE OR DONATE

There Aren’t Actually A Lot Of Places For Billionaires To Run

So, the news comes in that Mark Zuckerberg is not going to leave California even if the 5% wealth tax passes. Jensen Huang of Nvidia isn’t moving either. Some billionaires have, most notably Thiel to Argentina, and a few to Texas, but overall, most are staying in place.

A just-released SEC filing makes an extraordinary revelation: Mark Zuckerberg is getting ready to pay California’s 5% billionaire wealth tax and has signed an agreement to remain in California for 8 years.

Here’s the thing, there aren’t a lot of world class cities, and there are even fewer industrial and tech centers, for smart leaders who want to be where things are happening.

In the US there’s L.A, San Fran, New York and if you’re very political, DC. Chicago, Miami, Austin and Dallas are second tier options, but can be made to work. Boston seems to have fallen out of the great US cities, except for academia, but that’s under heavy assault.

In Europe there’s a few, but basically Paris and London are the main spots.

Japan has Tokyo, Dubai isn’t an option any more.

And that’s about it. Most billionaires aren’t willing to live in some regional city. As for moving tax domicile, it’s certainly possible, but only because Europe and the US allow it: it’s simple enough to tax all domestic income and go after foreign hidden money: when Switzerland tried to resist the IRS, the IRS broke them. You simply have to have the political will.


It’s my annual fundraiser. This allows us to cover the changeover of hegemony from America to China, environmental collapse, internal US fascism, what a better society would look like, Gaza, AI, the coming stock market crash and various other issues. As of this writing we’ve raised about $3,145 out of a $14,500 goal, from 38 people. It’d be great if you can help out (please don’t donate if your financial situation is dire.) You can Subscribe or Donate here or contact me at admin-at-ianwelsh-dot-net if you need another way to donate (mail, usually. A lot of cash apps don’t work in Canada.)


If we want to tax billionaires it’s not hard. Where are they going to go? China won’t take most of them, and if it does, it’s damn well going to tax them, and might even execute them if they pull the sort of fraud they routinely commit in the West. Russia isn’t an option any more. Tax havens exist only because they are allowed to exist.

There’s always an excuse for why we can’t tax the rich, but the most bogus one is that they’ll “just move”. That’s only true IF tax laws are set up to allow it and there’s no cooperation between countries. But basically any time the US and Europe get serious, it ends.

Of course it won’t end, yet, because billionaires own the governments of most countries. But nothing lasts forever, and the tide is turning.

 

A Billionaire Has A Psychotic Religious Break With Reality

Billionaires are powerful. Peter Thiel isn’t the richest billionaire in the world, but he is an American billionaire who runs the most important intelligence firm in the world, Palantir.

Thiel’s gay, a protestant, and appears to have gone stark raving mad. You’ve probably heard about his Antichrist lectures. A simple summary is:

Thiel has previously written and lectured on the subject, arguing that the Antichrist is not necessarily a person but could come as a global government system. It would take control, he has argued, by exploiting people’s fears around artificial intelligence, climate change or nuclear war.

Exploiting fears? Like the insane 72% of Americans who thought Iraq was involved in 9/11? The massive scare campaign around Iran?

No–actual legitimate issues. Climate change is real, nuclear war is possible and the very founders of AI constantly publicly worry about AI ending humanity. (Well perhaps the AI bit is bullshit.)

Now it’s possible that Thiel is just running an op–that he doesn’t believe any of this and is simply trying to whip up religious folks, especially Evangelicals (a religion that is reversal of much of what Jesus preached) against policies he hates. Being kind, perhaps he genuinely thinks that the world is in danger of world government and it will be achieved thru fear.

But I think it’s more likely he’s had a religious psychotic break, confusing his own desires and prejudices with religious teachings.

And the generous reading fades the more one knows:

He describes the ICC as part of the emerging ideological architecture of the Antichrist, likening language on the ICC’s website to the antichristic talk of peace and safety in 1 Thessalonians. Thiel notes that the ICC’s arrest warrants for Israeli PM Benjamin Netanyahu and former Defense Minister Yoav Gallant have limited where they can travel.

The ICC warrant meant Netanyahu couldn’t visit Poland on the 80th anniversary of the liberation of Auschwitz concentration camp; though Poland’s president said he wouldn’t enforce it, Poland’s authority to defy the ICC wasn’t clear, and so the Israeli PM didn’t come.

Hungary, which belong to the ICC, allowed Netanyahu to travel to their country, with zero consequences, so this is false.

But the bigger point is that he’s weaponizing the Bible to say that doing good is bad. Netanyahu has lead a genocide, there isn’t a single human rights org in the world that I know of that has concluded anything else, and anyone who two brain cells to rub together knows it is true, because it’s been livestreamed and Israeli politicians are very clear that they want to get rid of all Palestinians, and a super-majority of Israelis agree.

Thiel’s been very dedicated to this message. He repeats it over and over again.

And what he’s saying is batshit insane. He’s either gone crazy or is acting crazy and to some extent it doesn’t matter which.

But because he’s a billionaire, and an important one (the US Vice President is his creature, plus he’s shown a vicious willingness to use his power to destroy his enemies), no one has pointed that what he’s saying is crazy.

Being good at making money doesn’t mean you’re smart or wise about anything else. We hang on the words of billionaires as if they’re pearls of wisdom, but the more billionaires we have minted, the worse the economy has become for a super-majority of the population.

If you want a Bible quote, here’s one for you: “by their fruits you shall judge them.”

By the fruits of Western billionaires, they’re terrible people and any advice they give, whether they’re having a break with reality or not, are meant to benefit them and their class, and not anyone else.

Google made search worse to juice profits. Facebook knew scammers were on their site, knew who many of them were, and did nothing, because they were making money off them. We now have online gambling and prediction markets which make casinos look like a good deal. Enshitification is word, and a thing, and it’s driven by billionaires caring only about themselves and their profits.

Anyone who listens to them without running what they say through “this person only cares about themselves” is a fool.

But Thiel’s gone a step further. The Antichrist?

Come on.

This worship of wealth as meaning someone is wise and smart is foolish. Most of them are only good at making money and buying political power. But beyond that foolishness, a sane society would look at Thiel’s Antichrist claims and laugh him out of the public sphere as a lunatic. That we don’t shows how far our societies have fallen into “The Emperor’s New Clothes” territory.

Until we purge the entire oligarchic class in the West, we will never have widespread prosperity or an information commons which is useful. It’s that simple. In the meantime, can we at least not pretend that religious mania is worth listening to?

What I write here is for the benefit of everyone, but alas, I live in capitalism and I, and the site, take money to keep running. If you value the writing here and can, please subscribe or donate.

Buy, Borrow, Die—Another Way the Rich Avoid Taxes

One of the long term themes of my writing is that the rich have engineered a system in the West which insures they will continue to get richer, generally in a way which simultaneously impoverishes everyone else.

Buy, borrow, die is another example. The idea is simple enough: rich people

  1. Buy or otherwise obtain assets. Ideally these are assets which produce income or capital gains, but if you have a millions of dollars of stocks that works. This is one main reason for stock and option grants: they don’t register as income per se, and thus aren’t taxed as income but as capital, which means they aren’t taxed until you sell them, no matter how much they appreciate.
  2. Borrow is the next step: use your assets as collateral. Loan rates for the rich are usually 1.5 to 2% higher than short term treasury rates (which means that from 2008 to 2020 they were rarely more than 3%, they’re higher now, especially due to Trump’s insane war with Iran and its consequences for treasury rates. This rate of interest is far lower than you would pay for capital gains taxes, let alone income
  3. Die. When you die the price of your assets for estate tax purposes are reset to how much you bought them for. So your heirs pay taxes as if there had been no appreciation in asset prices.

This has been going on for a long time, but only become the default for “high net worth individuals” after 2008. It’s viable somewhere between ten and 30 million dollars of wealth.

In order for this to work, of course, you need to know that asset prices and returns on income producing assets will be higher than borrowing costs. Fortunately ever since Greenspan and his infamous Greenspan’s Put, the Federal Reserve has always insured that the stock market and asset prices in general, always rise fast. This has broken down a bit with real estate assets since 2020, but the stock market is reaching unseen highs regularly, and unlike in the pre-Reagan era, there are no sustained bear markets.

This is, again, a policy choice. It doesn’t have to be this way. Doing this in China would not work even if the law allowed it, because the stock market isn’t juiced and doesn’t provide essentially automatic increases. It does work in most, perhaps all Western nations, though in general other countries aren’t quite so permissive. The “die” part also required some significant changes to estate taxes for it to be viable for the merely rich (tens of millions) as opposed to the really rich with hundreds of millions or more.

As a result of this the rich often pay far less in taxes, as a percentage, than the upper middle class, especially highly paid professionals who still mostly get their money from wages.

I’m going to return to this later, but for now the important thing is simply to understand that the economy, which includes the tax system, is set up structurally to favor the rich. Yes, they still wind up paying a lot of taxes in absolute terms, but in proportional terms they often pay less than ordinary citizens. Warren Buffet famously noted that he paid a lower percentage of his income than his secretary did.

This is also organized to keep wealth together over generations, creating an oligarchic aristocracy, which is something America’s founders were very much opposed to. Along with permission for oligopoly, monopoly, price fixing and the structure of monetary production (many rich people are connected to banks and other financial firms which are allowed to create money out of thin air), plus law changes like Citizen’s United (money is speech so restrictions on election spending are illegal) this is a structural preference for oligarchy.

The only way to end this requires significant legislative changes, along with changes to the Supreme Court makeup, since as it stands right now the Supremes would strike down any laws intended to challenge oligarchy.

Since oligarchs own the politicians and the supreme court, this won’t happen unless the rich lose their power in a Great Crash that even the Fed and Treasury can’t bail them out from, and since they can print as much money as they want, that means it isn’t going to happen short of some sort of revolution. The money as speech decision makes it unlikely this will be an electoral revolution (though not entirely impossible), so it will likely require a full revolution.

If that doesn’t happen America’s decline will continue until it is just a larger version of Brazil or India: lots of poor people, a small but prosperous upper middle class who are direct retainers of the rich and a mass of poor people.

It’s quite clever really, the only downside is that this sort of financialization and rentierism weakens America as a whole since returns on manufacturing can’t match financial returns under this sort of economic engineering, and industrial power is effectively military power in the post-industrial revolution world.

America’s oligarchs have thus chosen American decline in exchange for what they hope is permanent oligarch status.

What I write here is for the benefit of everyone, but alas, I live in capitalism and I, and the site, take money to keep running. If you value the writing here and can, please subscribe or donate.

Page 1 of 101

Powered by WordPress & Theme by Anders Norén