is that people in democratic countries have some responsibility for what their countries do.
The horizon is as far as we can see. A time horizon is as far as we plan for, as far as we care about. The ancient Greeks had a proverb which runs as follows: “A society grows great when old men plant trees whose shade they know they will never sit in.”
The middle aged and old run society. They make up the bulk of senior executives and the bulk of powerful politicians.
The men and women who lived through the Great Depression always planned for the future. They built power plants which produced more power than needed, bridges which could handle more traffic, water purification plants which produced more water. They made sure infrastructure would last for decades, and then built it so well it outlasted even their specifications.
Their heirs, the Silents and the Boomers, thought this was absurd. Why not party now, and let the future take care of itself?
Call this the “death bet”. In it’s pure form, the death bet is just that, a bet that when the bill comes due, you’ll be dead. If you live a good life and die owing millions, well, what do you care?
But someone will pay that bill. Maybe it will be your creditors, who might even go out of business, unable to collect what they are owed. Perhaps it will be your heirs, if the millions adhere to property. Perhaps it will be someone you don’t even know.
But someone will pay. The good life, bought by debt, is always paid for.
The death bet is why we are not dealing with climate change, even though we know that it is coming and we know it will kill hundreds of millions and might even destroy our entire society. The death bet is why our governments make huge tax cuts today knowing that either taxes will have to be increased in the future or spending will have to be drastically cut. But in the meantime the government can borrow, or print money, so who cares? The politicians who make the tax cuts won’t be in power, and many of the people who receive the cuts will be dead, so what do they care?
The death bet is why America had a 2.4 trillion dollar infrastructure deficit as of 2009. It is why Californians voted in 1978 to disallow property tax increases of more than 2% per year. And it is why tuition rates have increased by hundreds of percentage points more than inflation in many countries.
A death bet always come due. It just isn’t always paid by those who made it. The GI generation who voted Reagan in are mostly dead, they won the death bet. Most of the Silents will win as well.
Only about half of Boomers are going to win the bet, though, and if you’re a Gen-X’er or below, unless you die young, you might want to stop taking death bets.
No society will remain prosperous if the time horizon is only so far as our grasp. rather than so far as we can see. The future always arrives, and the bill we’ve put off is always paid by someone.
I hope my readers had a good holiday season, and that your 2014 is better than 2013 was for you. Unless you were heavily invested in the stock market, or German, 2013 was a generally lousy year for most people in the Western world.
In the new year I’ll be making some decisions about how much, and what, to blog in 2014. The last few months of 2013 saw some major pieces on ideology, global warming and the history of our devolution to the semi-permanent crisis we’re in and the response to those articles was excellent, but they are a great deal of work.
On a personal level, 2013 was mostly about improving my health, and it’s quite a bit better than it was this time last year, so I’m grateful for that.
Take care of yourselves, and may the Fates be kind.
prompted by this Atlantic article on integrating women into combat, I thought I’d run through the basics (as I understand them), on this issue.
Let’s start with capability. On the con side, women generally:
- have less upper body strength;
- suffer stress fractures more easily;
- run more slowly.
On the plus side, women generally:
- have more long term endurance under adverse conditions. The list of endurance swimmers is as dominated by women as the list of weightlifters is by men: there are no male distance swimmers who can come even close to the best women. This translates into military jobs such as forward observing and sniping.
- Appear to have far better fire control than men.
On the even side:
- As best I can tell from looking at Olympic shooting and sniper records from WWII (where Russian female snipers feature on the list of top snipers), as well as anecdotally from gun-clubs, women are just as good a shot as men. A common joke runs that husbands try to convince their wives to shoot, then are upset when their wives are better than them.
In terms of capability, I don’t see a ton of argument for keeping women out of combat.
There are, however, social realities. The Israelis, who have a lot of experience with this, decided that the problem with women in combat wasn’t women, it was men: the men couldn’t get over the possibility of harm, or worse, coming to women. On the flip side, in the US military, rape by fellow soldiers is far too common.
And rape is likely to be the reality for women who are captured, as well. Do we want that? Men may be raped if captured, but they will not become pregnant as a result.
I do firmly believe that everyone in society should be combat trained. I think it ups the compliance costs for governments who wish to head in authoritarian directions for combat training to be given to the sort of people who normally wouldn’t have it. People who have authoritarian personalities are, generally, more comfortable with violence and more likely to be trained in its use. It’s good for society for everyone to have that training so authoritarians don’t have a near monopoly. It is for this reason that despite all the problems with it, I support the draft: when the US moved to a volunteer army, made up primarily of southerners, it created a dangerous situation: an army that is not representative of the population, which considers itself (and is considered) superior to civilians.
Combat training, however, is not the same as being combat troops. Everyone may receive Basic and even some advanced training, without being expected to fight except in the most desperate of situations.
Finally, if a nation does want to go down the route of female combatants, I tend to think that combat units should be gender segregated: this protects women from both men’s concern in combat, where it is inappropriate, and from their predation back on base.
me, I’m eating duck, so Christmas is good.
We, in the West, live in scarcity economies. The key bottleneck resources are scarce, and the decision has been made to keep them scarce. Our entire economic policy from about 1979 can be summarized as follows: ordinary people cannot be allowed to have a real raise which translates into spending on oil.
When Bush screwed up the second part of that, and oil went to 150, it was one of the major causes of the financial collapse.
In a rich society, like the one we had in the 60s and 70s, big projects get completed. The interstate freeway system; the moon shot; the huge build-out of the university system. Artists and musicians sprout everywhere, good jobs exist in abundance, it’s not hard to make a living, so you can do what you want most of the rest of the time, and you can tell your Boss to go screw himself if he treats you badly. (Even in the mid eighties, I could do this. I knew I’d be employed the next day, and I had no special skills, NONE.)
When you live in a scarcity society, it’s almost impossible to receive permission to do anything real, and you have to put up with how your boss treats you, unless you have a very in-demand skillset, because the next job isn’t a sure thing. Infrastructure isn’t maintained, new institutions aren’t built, and every old institution tries to create a rental stream (thus the huge increases in tuition and the huge decreases in grants.) You can’t build high-speed rail, heck you can’t even maintain the freeways properly. Bridges start collapsing, and so on.
(I am fundraising to determine how much I’ll write this year. If you value my writing, and want more of it, please consider donating.)
This isn’t just about resource shortages. A resource shortage may start the sequence, but it is the deliberate refusal to deal with the resource shortage which turns it from a challenge into an era, which turns a rich society into a scarcity society.
When America and the West turned away from Carter (as flawed as he was) and turned towards Reagan (a disciple of Thatcher), they made a choice not to deal with the oil bottleneck except through scarcity rationing. The deliberate policy of the 80s and 90s all centered around NAIRU – the non accelerating inflation rate of unemployment. The idea was that if the unemployment rate was too tight, wages would increase, spiking inflation. So unemployment had to be kept high enough so that inflation would not occur. This is one form of inflation – so-called wage push inflation.
So whenever ordinary people started to get raises higher than the rate of inflation, the Fed would say “this rate of unemployment is lower than the NAIRU” and crush the economy and wages.
This is because wages went to doing things which increased oil prices, and Fed wanted oil prices crushed and inflation in general crushed.
The unemployment rate is, thus, not a measure of how many people are out of work, it is a measure of how close the labor market is to being tight enough to allow ordinary people to get a raise that is higher than the inflation rate.
There are a bunch of concomitants to this policy, too many to go into, but just note that is part and parcel of creating the richest rich the world has ever seen and creating asset bubbles. Money can only be created IF it won’t do anything that really matters, because anything that matters will cause oil prices to spike.
(It is also for this reason that despite all the problems fracking causes, your Lords and Masters will despoil as much of the country as necessary to continue to do so, it’s another way around the oil bottleneck.)
Note that there were other choices: massive investment in renewable energy; massive investment in energy conservation; massive investment in public transit, and a move from the suburbs back to the cities, with walkable cities. In the 90s the move should have been to telecommuting. A national income which pays people not to drive to work every day, insistent carpooling and so on, could have mitigated this problem extremely. Call the early parts of this the “super analog future that never happened.”
If you do all those things, though, the rich don’t get insanely rich, and the middle class doesn’t get to run away from black people to the suburbs. Americans voted for suburbia and against black people (and don’t tell me otherwise, I remember Reagan’s campaign, and it was based on racism). The people who made those votes, the Reagan Democrats, mostly won their bet: their house prices went up, they didn’t have to live near people with melanin, and they retired wealthy and went to live in the south, where brown people wiped their butts.
But the price of this was the end of the rich society. The end of a society where you could tell your boss to go screw himself. And it was the end of a society in which big projects were regularly undertaken. Oil is wonderful energy: it is highly dense and easily transportable, and lets you do what you want, where you want. Using oil to make plastics, to enable suburbia, to be incredibly wasteful, meant that all the big things could no longer be done.
The concomitant of this policy was the creation of the super-rich, and that meant the destruction of real Western democracy, as country after country found its politicians more and more controlled by the rich. The rich do not want change unless they control the change. Any change that already rich people can’t figure out how to control and monetize is not allowed. The state is turned into a machine for giving money and preferments to the already rich and powerful, its oversight role is hollowed out and its taxation ability is scuppered.
The great projects of the past, even when done by private enterprise, were underwritten by government. Poor governments (and yes, despite the trillions, the US government is poor) cannot engage in these huge projects.
With money printing and low interest rate borrowing monopolized by the financial sector, and within the financial sector, by a rather small number of institutions, and with demanded rates of return at least in the teens, most new businesses and projects were not, and are not, viable, in the sense that they will not be funded. Can you compete with the returns of the housing market pre 2007 (leveraged) or the leveraged returns of the stock market in the past 30 years, a stock market backed up by the Bernanke and Greenspan Puts (the knowledge that if the market goes down, the government will step in to make sure it goes back up?)
You can’t. So money floods to the highest returns, which are financial paper returns, bubbling way off the surface of the economy, and instead of building a high speed rail system, or making every building in your country energy neutral, or going to Mars, or crashing solar technology much sooner and harder, or…. anything else you want, pretty much, you get financial bubbles and history’s richest rich.
Living in a rich society is different from living in a scarcity society. There is money to create big projects. There is money to tell your boss where to go. There are jobs. Ordinary people have pricing power in a tight labor market and can get their share of productivity gains.
No society is rich in everything, there are always limitations. But being rich, personally or as a society, is about freedom. When you have money you can do what you want, when you want.
We could create a rich society again. It is possible. The necessary technology is there. What is not there are the social determinants. As long as the public and private sphere are controlled by oligarchs, there will be no rich society.
If you enjoyed this article, and want me to write more, please DONATE or SUBSCRIBE.
The Fed had finally decided to reduce purchases (from 85 billion a month to 75 billion.) I will simply note that 10 billion from the Fed doesn’t matter all that much when other Central Banks (like the the Bank of Japan) are also doing the same thing (and Japan is talking about increasing such purchases) and when China is creating far more new money than the US.
China does have currency controls, but they are less and less effective, but most other countries do not. It matters little if it is Japan or the US engaging in these policies, the money goes transnational.
I do not, thus, expect this to have much effect. So long as developed nations banks are as a group flushing the markets with money, and so long as China does have a financial crisis, this economy can go on for many more years like this, especially as the various bubbles are being reinflated, in large part with leaking Chinese money. Expect the stock market to continue to rise, with occasional selloffs, but generally in an upwards trend. Expect housing prices in most markets to continue to rise as well. Expect large corporations, especially financial corporations, to continue to make money. Expect the rich to continue to get richer.
Don’t expect that to mean your personal economy will get any better, mind you. Any improvements will be marginal.
The Earth is a dangerous place, and humans make it more so. There are many scenarios, from nuclear war, to designer diseases, to nanotech goo, too environmental catastrophe where we can wipe ourselves out. Further, there are events almost entirely beyond our control, like meteor impacts, which could wipe us out. The Earth is a mass-graveyard: most species which have ever existed are extinct.
The Earth is a single point of failure. If all self-sustainable human breeding populations are on Earth, we are much more likely to go extinct, and far sooner.
Getting of the rock is about human survivability in the longer run. Getting out into the solar system, learning how to create habitats and breeding populations, increases our viability. Spreading to other solar systems, whenever we can, will increase it even further.
On the other hand, if we stay on Earth, especially given how incapable we are of acting in basic racial self-interest (as proved by climate change) our odds of an extinction event, and soon, go way, way up.
If you enjoyed this article, and want me to write more, please DONATE or SUBSCRIBE.