Nothing Can Be Done When People Believe Lies

Former CIA Agent John Stockwell on the CIA’s propaganda war on Cuba:

“We pumped dozens of stories about Cuban atrocities…we didn’t know of a single atrocity committed by the Cubans. It was pure false propaganda to create an illusion of communists eating babies for breakfast.”

One of the most fundamental reasons the world is screwed up is that most people believe a bunch of lies. This can be flagrant, like the “drones of death” Iraq supposedly had, ore that Iran killed 50K protestors or that Iraqi troops bayoneted babies in Kuwait.

But it can also be subtle. The generations long understatement of inflation in the consumer price index, for example, means that people lost a third of their actual purchasing power (or more) while the government gaslit them.

Everyone’s walking around talking about stats which have no relation the real world and which predict nothing. It’s like GDP: “Spain’s GDP is about the same as Russia’s.”

So? GDP measures the market value (price) of what your country is spending money on. That’s all. It doesn’t tell you how much industrial capacity they have: how many drones, artillery shells and weapons they can create. Whether or not they can generate their own energy without imports. Whether they can feed themselves. Whether their energy grid could survive mass adoption of air conditioning (hello Britain.) Britain’s water companies added a lot to GDP while flushing sewage into rivers.

American intelligence recently noted that Iran had repaired most of the damage from the first part of the war. But Iran’s GDP is tiny.

Turns out, however, that since they couldn’t buy industrial and construction goods for so long, they became good at making them themselves. Sanctions mean they mostly can’t sell to foreign markets, so they don’t show up much in GDP, but they have the capacity. Meanwhile the US has a massive GDP and takes years to build or repair a bridge that China can fix in weeks or building in months.

We’re swimming in a sea of toxic bullshit. The “facts” our decision-making apparatus uses are often just straight wrong. The population is lied to even more systematically.

If I were writing laws it’d be a mandatory prison sentence for a politician or government official to knowingly lie to the public. No one can make good decisions with bad facts.

Now this isn’t to say that often we do have good facts and do the wrong thing anyway. I’m old enough to remember the doctor shortage in Canada being predicted back in the late 80s, especially the shortage of family physicians. Same with the nurse shortage.

The solution was obvious: train more doctors and nurses. This takes time: more medical school slots, more residencies, etc… But we knew well in advance. We did nothing except think “we can steal doctors and nurses from the third world”, then make it hard for them to work in Canada.

So good facts alone won’t save you. But bad facts make it hard to do the right thing even if you wanted to. Just before the Iraq War over 70% of Americans thought that Iraq was behind 9/11. There is zero evidence of that. There was zero evidence of that back then. But if you believe a lie, you may act on the lie and so Americans supported the war.

For going on 40 years we’ve been making our statistics not reflect reality. This was deliberate, because low inflation stats meant low adjustments to pensions, wages and so on. GDP goes up as the only statistic that mattered concealed that the industrial base was being offshored, which made some people very very rich.

Some people knew the lies were lies, but many didn’t, and the longer the lies continued the more people forgot they were lies.

Till reality (that grocery bill) became impossible to ignore, but compromised stats made it nearly impossible to make the argument to do something.

Lying is a primal sin exactly because it makes even understanding a problem either impossible or much worse. I lie is how we change the world into something fake but better for us. It’s one thing to say “my dog ate my homework”, it’s another for public officials to lie so that some people benefit and others (always a much larger group) suffer. If it was up to me a politician or government official knowingly lying would carry a mandatory prison sentence.

Our “masters” have completely forgotten that democracy is supposed to be about service to the people. Politicians work for the public, not the other way around.

At least in theory. But the further the theory moves from practice, the more politicians act for any reason other than the common weal, the more they need to lie so they can do what they really want. In this era, mint more billionaires.

The complete normalcy of government lies, politely called propaganda, conceals the sort of rot which destroys civilizations, and it’s helping destroy ours.

What I write here is for the benefit of everyone, but alas, I live in capitalism and I, and the site, take money to keep running. If you value the writing here and can, please subscribe or donate.