The horizon is not so far as we can see, but as far as we can imagine

Don’t Believe Weekend “Peace Deal” Leaks

So, this weekend there was a leak of a possible peace deal. Iran got most of what it wanted in this hypothetical deal. Israel said “we won’t obey any truce in Lebanon” and, well, that’s probably the end of it, though we’ll see.

I considered writing about it over the weekend, but so far every peace deal floated over a weekend has meant a manipulation of markets, some insider making bank by exactly timing it, and no peace deal.

The bottom line here is that if Iran is serious about a peace deal including Lebanon and Hezbollah, it can only happen if Trump is willing and able to discipline Israel. Doing so is in one sense easy: just stop sending them weapons and parts. They can’t go more than two weeks without US re-supply. (This is why Netanyahu has been saying Israel wants to be independent of the US.)

For whatever reason Trump won’t do this. It could be political fear due to the power of the lobby. It could be they have pictures of him raping kids. It could be, as a correspondent just argued, that in fact Trump is impotent and they can prove that and his ego can’t take it.

Whatever the reason is, it obviously exists.

Iran would like a deal, but it’s in no particular rush because the pain ramps up every week the Strait of Hormuz stays closed, and despite what various idiots say, the US is not immune to that pain.

Iran won the war. They want a peace deal that reflects that. They aren’t willing to give in peace what the US can’t win by arms.

As for the US, I think we’re looking at an opposition between American politicians fear of Israel and its lobby and their terror of what will happen in the mid-term elections. The Joker in the deck is the how many of them are subject to blackmail, because pictures of them raping teenagers trumps losing election.

Deleted AIPAC tweet

But be clear that the pain has only begun. It’s going to be even worse overseas. If Europe and large parts of Asia, including Australia, don’t start rationing soon, they’re not going to have enough energy to get thru next winter. That’s the sort of incompetence that leads to governments falling.

If the US was run by sane competent non-blackmailed people who cared about America, and not just their own class, Trump would be impeached, Israel would be reined in, and a peace deal would be cut. The US has lost, and the fallout from signing a peace deal which admits this is less than letting the Strait remain closed.

If this or another similar deal does pass soon, then it will be because Iran has cut Hezbollah loose and left them on their own, whatever they say. But trying to help Hezbollah isn’t just about doing the “right thing”, Hezbollah is an important proxy for Iran and they want to keep it around and not have to support it in a multi-year war against Israel.

And, again, their negotiating hand gets stronger every day. Sure, they’re suffering from the US blockade, but not as much as the US (and almost everyone else) is from theirs.

The only country which could compel Iran to make peace is China, and since they are run by competent people who think ahead, they’re one of the few nations that can handle the Strait being closed. Not, perhaps, forever, but certainly much longer than the US can.

Meanwhile America keeping the Strait closed (which is how it is perceived by many) is doing vast damage to America’s subject states. That too will have consequences: they may publicly blame Iran, but behind the scenes they know this was a US war of choice, that the US lost, and that the US doesn’t care what is happening to them as a consequence of not cutting a peace deal.

Losing wars has consequences. Failing to admit you lost a war has even worse consequences. The US has yet to figure this out.

 

What I write here is for the benefit of everyone, but alas, I live in capitalism and I, and the site, take money to keep running. If you value the writing here and can, please subscribe or donate.

Previous

Freedom To, Freedom From & Capitalism (Freedom Series #3)

6 Comments

  1. Feral Finster

    “Iran would like a deal, but it’s in no particular rush because the pain ramps up every week the Strait of Hormuz stays closed, and despite what various idiots say, the US is not immune to that pain.”

    As long as the stock markets can continue to remain buoyant, nobody cares. Hence, Trump is in no rush to make a deal. Yes, millions will suffer and die, but neither Trump nor rich people anywhere care, as long as the police and army will shot when ordered.

    Moreover, there is no deal that Iran can make that will satisfy Israel. This is why Trump sticks new conditions, such as requiring the remaining gulfie tyrannies to recognize Israel.

  2. Feral Finster

    “The only country which could compel Iran to make peace is China, and since they are run by competent people who think ahead, they’re one of the few nations that can handle the Strait being closed.”

    China simply wants to sell things and make money, which is why they pressured Iran into the asinine ceasefire in the first place.

    The Americans, by contrast, care only for power, domination and control, and are perfectly willing to harm others and themselves not to lose these things.

  3. Bob

    This is all so maddeningly insane.
    I am tending to believe the story that the energy supply is about to drop off a cliff but no matter how bitter and cynical I am I can’t believe our useless governments are seemingly unaware of any potential problems. Don’t worry, book your flights to the Canaries! Arrange a dinner party!

  4. Mark Level

    Hi, Ian. As usual, you nail it, except for one typo (sorry for being pedantic, a former English and ESL teacher, I can’t help it.) 2nd paragraph after the Black box Massie-related Tweet, you say Israel being “reigned in”, you mean “reined in” the homonym for controlling a horse while riding. You can’t rule somebody in, though I suppose a Referee could rule someone in or out of bounds, e.g.

    English has so many homonyms that contradict one another, used to teach my students that one can raise a lantern or fist, an army can raze a village, complete opposite concepts.

    As to your main point, all sensible, I think on your list of reasons for DJT to Taco it’s ALL, with the biggest one being his fragile Ego and having started a war that most (even that evil scumbag Robert Kagan) now admit is lost, not Fox News or foaming-at-the-mouth Hegseth, but all who are sane and somewhat informed.

    I too ignored this, other than infrequent checks on news reports, ‘coz I know he’s incompetent and entirely owned. And I make it a rule never to believe anything the US Government says. There are very rare exceptions, but still–.

    I think the most important thing for ‘Muricans in your post is that the European Slugs (the populace, not Kaja Kallas and that set) will know who starves and freezes them, US will, as you indicate, become as big a Pariah state in EUrope, the Global South, even Australia (a complete suck-up, but as you said, 3 meals away from a revolution, Lenin’s quip) and others will hate the US for doing to them what US did to Russia between 1991-97, complete impoverishment across the board.

    It’s gonna get ugly. Oh, and not too off-topic, Tony’s very first curated link on Sunday about the up to 295K people leaving the US last year, found an excellent video here which I shared with a family member in Flori-duh, she wants to get out, but not necessarily out of USA. Link to follow. I think the 18-year old youth who got out is most inspirational but they all make good points: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qgRXzOy_O9w

    Kind regards, you have the best (imho) website covering politics, economics, philosophy, literature and so much else I won’t bother to list, your writing is nearly always deeply inspirational and spot-on.

  5. Ian Welsh

    Yes, homonyms are my writing kryptonite. I think in sound when writing. Thanks for the catch.

  6. Ian Welsh

    There’s a real economy, and it matters. Thinking only the stock market matters is falling for oligarch propaganda.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Powered by WordPress & Theme by Anders Norén