Ian Welsh

The horizon is not so far as we can see, but as far as we can imagine

An update on the effect of the price of shipping oil and tax on exports

From Skuppers, in comments:

In February, the Fuel Surcharge (FSC) on shipments was 26%. It is now 31%. It keeps climbing with no end in sight. It’s not always a straight formula though, as I saw an invoice from the steam line the other day, where the customer’s freight rate is $1400, but the added FSC was about $1800. Adding a margin? Lol. But really what I want to add here could be best captured by this title: Cynical, naive, or just dumb?

In July 2010, the government instituted a tax incentive to businesses to get exports moving. I would guess their motivation was to encourage exports to increase profits to get companies to hire more workers. You know, work on that unemployment thing. So they give a tax break to exporters, and reduce their tax on profits from 35% to 15%.

My customer in Australia imports a lot of pork. They are owned by a U.S. company that supplies about 60% of their product. They got their product delivered FAS Long Beach, meaning free along side. The supplier paid for all expenses up to the side of the ship; rail to long beach, transloading, and delivery to the ship. My customer paid for everything from that point on – I acted as their agent, and so I was “technically” the exporter. Starting in August, the supplier wanted to sell the product, in order to take advantage of the tax incentive, DES – delivered ex-ship. Meaning they paid for all expenses up to the point that the ship tossed the container overboard at the foreign port. The supplier was now the exporter, in name, where they hadn’t been so before.

Was there any increase in exports? No; same business being done as before. Did the supplier hire new staff to handle the “new business?” No, in fact they let staff go; I’m still managing the shipments and getting my same ‘cut.’ So on paper, it looks like the supplier increased business by about 700 containers a year, and get a reduction of 20 points in those profits, but they haven’t really increased business, they just get the tax break.

This is just ONE business in the U.S. How many others are doing the same thing? So is the administration cynical, naive, or just dumb? Didn’t they do their homework on this? It took me about 5 minutes to figure this scheme out. How come the geniuses at Department of Commerce didn’t see this coming? Or did they? Is this just another way to get around the repatriation of foreign earned profits taxes by ‘reimbursing’ them at home (after all, money is fungible isn’t it?)?

Obama to Right Wing

“I agree with you, now make me do it”

(what FDR said to the left, if you aren’t aware.)

See, he is the new FDR!

Lambert and Corrente Need Help

If you value what Corrente and Lambert do, and you can afford it, consider tossing Corrente some money.  Blogging isn’t free, someone’s labor is always involved.  Corrente punches above its weight, the big dogs in the blogosphere may not link to it, but they definitely do read it, it’s sort of the guilty pleasure of many a-listers.  Ideas which start in Corrente do circulate out, and within Corrente there is a community which actually gets things done, as when they were the movers behind an alternate conference on the debt and deficit.

Times are hard for a lot of people, and if you don’t have the money, of course don’t give, but if you can afford it and you think Corrente does good work, help them out.

In Light of the Budget Deal: Obama’s Personality

Sometimes our early take on a man is the best.  In 2006, I wrote “I believe Obama“. (Re-repost, because it seems… appropriate.)

One of my rules of analysis is that I believe people when they tell me who they are. That doesn’t mean I believe everything they say – I never believed Bush was a moderate, for example, because I believed what he told me when he refused to correct obviously false budget numbers. His budget plan spent the surplus twice, and I believed that’s what he would do. And, needless to say, I was right (well sort of, he spent even more than that, but you get the point.)

People tell you who they are all the time, all you have to do is listen, separate out the noise intended to distract you, and then believe them. Bush’s record of failure at everything he did, for example, was clear. His slurring of words and inability to talk coherently was clear. His code-speaking to the Christian right was clear. All these things were there to see in 2000.

So, let’s talk about someone else. Obama. I’ve been listening to Obama and I’ve been hearing what he has to say. He’s been pretty hostile to the netroots, contemptuous and dismissive, and I’ve heard that and I believe it. Obama is telling me he has no respect for the sort of people who make up the netroots. I think he’s sincere – I don’t think it’s “just” a tactical move. He genuinely dislikes people getting worked up over issues. It makes him uncomfortable. He wants everything and everyone to be “nice”. I believe him when his words and actions tell me that, just as when he backed down from McCain when McCain unfairly attacked him, I believed what that told me about his spine and about the fact that he prefers peace to conflict, even when he’s in the right. I believe him when he says he admires John McCain and that he admires Joe Lieberman and I understand what that says about him (because, of course, if you actually follow McCain and Lieberman you know they aren’t even close to men of their word. And Obama knows that.)

Obama has told me who he is, and I have listened. If he gets into power he will compromise/compromise/compromise, because he believes in it – not as a means, but as an end. He will shy away from big fights, because he doesn’t like fighting. He may “believe” in universal healthcare, but he believes in compromise more. And I’m betting I know which belief will win out.

I’m sure many will disagree, but when people tell me who they are I listen. Obama has spoken, I’ve listened, and since I don’t believe that compromise is an end rather than just a means, he’s not the person I think should be president.

When Medicare is destroyed is only a matter of when

Folks, this won’t pass this year, but a version of it will pass:

That plan would transform Medicare from a government insurance program to one in which seniors would chose from private, federally subsidized coverage. Americans 55 and older would stay in the current system.

Remember, Obama’s health care reform was essentially the Republican plan from the 90s.  The Republicans, whom everyone was sneering at for running crazies, have put in place a team of hard right ideologues, who have moved DC significantly to the right even of where it was.  At some point they will pass this, because they want it badly, and the Democrats have no alternative vision other than “right wing, but not as right wing”, which goes nowhere.

I’ve said this before: get out.  If you can’t get out, get your kids out.  This is not going to end well.  Obama has institutionalized Bush rather than rolling him back, and in some areas, such as civil liberties and unilateral Presidential war powers, has actually moved further to the right than Bush was.  It is not impossible that this will get better in the next couple decades (as 5 year old Ian once argued, almost nothing is impossible), but it is unlikely.  Americans spent the last 35 years spending their retirement, their children’s retirement and running infrastructure and capital into the ground, and they were good with that.  Every effort to repeal Prop 13, for example, failed miserably.  America is the culture of the free lunch, what Americans don’t realize is that they’re the free lunch.

That doesn’t mean the US couldn’t fix its problems, in theory, but the point is that socially and politically, the US does not want to fix its problems.  It wants to continue to make them worse.  Yes, a majority of Americans may prefer different policies on some issues, but they aren’t willing to MAKE it happen or to actually pay for it (see Prop 13 above).  They aren’t willing to die for it, and at this point, that’s what it would take because your elites see no reason not take everything you have and turn you into slaves in all but name.  You will be debt slaves, who own almost nothing, not your house, not your phone, not your car, not your books.  Anything which can be rented to you, rather than than sold, will be.

Welcome to the Repo culture.  Everything you have, everything you are, can be taken away from you, and you are nothing but a series of revenue streams to your lords and masters.  Fail to pay, and you won’t even be allowed to be a debt and wage slave, you’ll be in a cardboard box or a debtor’s prison.

Modern Americans are mostly descended from people who didn’t say “this pisshole country is worth fighting for”, they’re descended from people who said “screw this, I’m outta here”.  Emulate them and leave, if you can’t leave do the other thing they were willing to do: prepare for a revolution and be willing to die in it.

Or accept your fate as slaves.

Your choice.

1984 Was Not A Manual

But the people running England, or at least London, certainly think it is.  CCTV cameras are everywhere you go, in large numbers.  On one Underground  platform today I counted 13.  Of course, with that many CCTV cameras there is no way they can actually effectively be monitored in real time, so they prevent crime only by threat of being caught later, and thus have no preventative effect that I can see against anyone who doesn’t care (like, say, suicide bombers).

But, of course, if you have nothing to hide, I’m sure you don’t mind the government recording everything you do, eh?

Oh, and men with submachineguns at Parliament?  Don’t make me feel safer, quite the reverse.  But, of course, they aren’t meant to make me or any other ordinary person feel safe, just like Britain’s government policies aren’t intended to make ordinary people more prosperous.

Other than that, very much enjoying London.  Cool Britannia’s days may be numbered, but it ain’t quite dead yet.

No Free Lunch

I haven’t had much to say about the Japanese Tsunami and the nuclear mess there, but here’s the short and to the point.

First: the reactors in question were not properly built and tested.  It is very clear now that the Japanese nuclear industry, as with the American, has been cutting corners to save money.  Let this be a warning, there is no free lunch.  If you skimp on such features, it will inevitably come back to haunt you.  If you want to stop this sort of thing, start sending executives to jail for negligent homicide, otherwise expect it to continue.

Second: this is going to lead to a huge round of the stupids.  Contrary to what many on the left think, widescale solar is still not feasible, the production of large solar panels produces huge amounts of toxic byproducts.  So if Japan wants to go off nukes, they would most likely go off them to coal, and if you replace all those nukes with that much coal, it’s a complete environmental and health disaster, and a massive downshift in standard of living, to boot.

Third: Japan poured a pile of concrete in the last couple decades, including in the last 2 years.  They could have poured concrete over the backup generators in plants like this, instead of making roads to nowhere, but they didn’t.  Japan’s technocrats are, fundamentally, incompetent.  Perhaps not as incompetent as America’s, but in the same general boat, as are all the developed world’s technocrats.

The choice is being made, today, to deny, deny, deny reality.  The reality is that the energy bottleneck has to be dealt with.  And the reality is that the only technology ready right now, which can be scaled, which could tide us over the 20 years we need, is probably nuclear.  But the plants we have were designed not as civilian plants, but as dual use plants able to produce material for nuclear weapons.  They were deliberately designed to not be particularly safe and even the safety features they theoretically have, as with the Gulf disaster, have had corners cut so severely that they aren’t safe.

Nuclear power might be relatively safe, but not built by us, not by this society.  But the other options are disastrous as well.  As a practical matter, we are going to be moving more and move to coal, shale oil and tar sands oil.  And that economy is ugly as hell, and an environmental disaster.

I know a lot of my readers aren’t going to like this, and the anti-nukers are going to freak out in the comments thread, but this is where we are.

Burning down your house to generate heat

Some years ago I worked for a large insurance company.  I was originally hired to help deal with a class action suit, but soon found myself working on something different, demutualizing the company.  Mutual insurance companies are owned by their customers, not by shareholders.  This has a number of advantages, but it means you don’t have shares, and thus buying out other companies requires cash, and you yourself can’t be bought.  You also can’t give stock options to your executives (not a small matter, these days).

Mutual companies also have one big social benefit: they provide insurance cheaper, because they don’t have to pay dividends or stock options and they return profits beyond those expected to the policy owners.  (Stock options supposedly don’t have a price, but they do in effect, both because of the rampant use of company profits for buybacks and because of how they change company behavior.)

Demutualization requires a vote by the shareholders.  There was never any question that it would pass, however, since it amounted to cashing out a lot of money.  For big policy owners the take could be in the millions, for smaller ones ten to twenty thousand wasn’t uncommon.

This part is important, so pay attention: this was the first cashing out moment, and what it was was a transfer from the past and future to the present.  Going forward every future policy holder would pay more money for their policies in order that the current generation could take out value.

The price of the shares was set at about $18 dollars, as I recall, they fell a couple bucks, then they spent the next two years rising, peaking around $40.  The CEO had bought five million dollars of shares at the initial price, which everyone knew was less than the company was worth, he did very well.

But the real change was driven by what is called “market’ discipline”.  Suddenly we needed to make 15% profits every year.

Insurance isn’t a business where you should be making that sort of profit.  Virtually no business is, but insurance in particular should be stodgy and boring and conservative, because its job is to be there when the customer takes their losses.

Friends would ask me about the company in those years, and I would say “it’s being run reasonably well, considering, but they’re burning down the house to make the profits.”

What do I mean by that?  They were pushing out senior junior employees.  In the pension department, for example, almost all of the senior customer service reps were gone within two years.  Why?  Because the new regime expected insane numbers from them.  Those numbers could only be produced by, well, lying to management.

Meanwhile, every month the sales numbers were being manipulated more and more, with sales which hadn’t actually completed being moved forward as if they had been.  Jobs were taylorized and de-skilled, so that employees had no real knowledge of the process, this in a company with the highest average face amount (amount covered, like a million dollars or 10 million) in the industry.

Products were designed overly fine, so that if customers missed a single payment by even a week, they would likely go into default, but those losses wouldn’t show up for years, since it would take time for the defaults to occur.

And the company went out and bought a big, moribund insurer, with an extraordinarily sick corporate culture and then struggled to make it work.

Bottom line: that company couldn’t make 15% without cutting corners which shouldn’t be cut.  You can provide worse customer service to multi-million dollar clients for a few years, but eventually your rep catches up with you.  My job was to deal with those customers, and as mistakes and problems occurred, I would burn through my social capital.  Most of my clients loved me, but there are only so many problems people will tolerate.  The same sort of thing was happening everywhere.  Eventually it came home to roost, and they stopped sending us as much new business.

For a few years, heck, for a decade, it mostly looked good to outsiders.  The company produced its 15%, the stock did well, and everyone outside the company was happy.

Then the shit hit the fan in 2008, and the company took the shock badly compared to equivalent competitors.  All of the corners they had cut came back to haunt them.

When you have a good company, product or service, you can always cash it out. You just cut corners for years, and cruise on your reputation.  And for years, it works, until it doesn’t.

Which brings us to this news story, about how the fashion company Hermes doesn’t want to be bought out by a conglomerate.

Family members recoil as they recall an LVMH official’s suggestion that Hermès bolster sales by creating a line of lower-priced bags.“It’s exactly what you shouldn’t do,” Mr. Dumas says. “Because you will make a cheap Hermès bag which will sell like hotcakes for three years, and after three years people will say, ‘Hermès is not what it used to be.’ ”

Mr. Thomas says: “If you tell me I have to double the profit of Hermès, I will do it tomorrow. But then you’d have no Hermès left in five years.”

There’s a man who gets it.

Here’s the rule, whenever greed becomes a primary motivator, and an acceptable primary motivator in a society, the society burns itself down.  It extracts money by destroying actual long term value.  This has been going on in the West, with its most extreme forms in the US, for over 30 years.

But as a society, what you get is money while destroying actual value.  The society as a whole is poorer than it would have been otherwise.

An actual capitalist society (which we do not live in) makes cashing out very difficult.  You don’t want people creating money by destroying value, and you don’t want viable ongoing concerns arbitrarily destroyed or weakened.  Whenever a company is bought out by borrowing the money, then making that company take on a loan to pay back the original loan and then another loan to pay the buyers even more money, money has been extracted while value has been destroyed (layoffs and other cost cutting inevitably follow).

As a society, allowing this sort of behaviour is death.  You must make sure that people do better by adding value than by destroying it.  Forceful short term extraction of money destroys value.  The only profits that most people should see are long term profits.  Want to get rich?  Great.  Either create something genuinely new under the sun (and no, Facebook is not something genuinely new, it is merely the winner in a market someone was going to win) or stick it out for a good twenty to forty years, taking your legitimate profit each year.

When you make it possible for people to get rich by destroying jobs that actually create value, by destroying companies which are actually viable, you are destroying your own society’s prosperity.

Page 467 of 532

Powered by WordPress & Theme by Anders Norén