Ian Welsh

The horizon is not so far as we can see, but as far as we can imagine

9/11

is a day which should be a reminder of how fear can make a people give up their liberties and prosperity and, in response to an atrocity, commit worse atrocities.

Ontario NDP leader promises no income tax raises

Guess I just gave my last donation to the Ontario NDP while she’s leader.  If I want Tory policies, I’ll vote for the real thing.

Although I am looking forward to the next fundraising call.

The Short on the President’s “Job Plan”

The plan is supposedly 447 billion.  By my count about 253 billion of that is in tax cuts.  Corporations are sitting on a ton of money, tax cuts will not make them hire.  Minor tax cuts for households will be used primarily for debt de-leveraging unless there is a general recovery with wage increases, since people will not spend in a depressionary environment.  Most of the spending is on projects which are run by states, and the money is fungible and will be effectively diverted to avoid tax increases.

There are no structural fixes for what is wrong with the economy here.  There is nothing to deal with the fact that even if it did work (it won’t) it would cause a run up in commodity prices, especially oil, which would crush the recovery anyway.  There is nothing to deal with the fact that most US banks are still bankrupt, except some incentives for Americans to buy houses so securitization can continue.  There is nothing to stop employers from calculation the tax rebates as effective raises, and thus not offering raises themselves (which is what they will do.)  There is nothing to make any corporation which already doesn’t pay taxes (more than you want to think about) to pay those taxes.

This stimulus is more than half tax cuts, which is worse than the first stimulus.  It is not as large as the first stimulus.  It will probably save or create a few jobs, but it will not kick the country out of depression.

All of this even assuming you’re stupid enough to believe this will pass as envisioned.  It won’t.  Obama is a weak president, and the Republicans will not pass most of the useful parts of this bill, though no doubt they’ll be happy to pass the tax cuts.

Oh, and Obama wants the entire thing offset by deficit reduction.  Given how weak a stimulus this is to begin with, I predict that if passed with offsets it WILL DO MORE DAMAGE TO THE ECONOMY THAN GOOD.

I see various progressives who think talk matters are cheering the wording of Obama’s speech.  He sure does talk purdy, doesn’t he?  Reminds me of his promises during the election campaign, in fact.

(White House Fact Sheet) (pdf)

The basics

To paraphrase many of the greatest religious and moral leaders, there is only one law: imagine you are in someone else’s shoes, then treat them as you would wish to be treated.

Or, put another way, act towards everyone as if you loved them.

The vast majority of political and economic commentary on this blog is commentary derived from those postulates.  Note that they are postulates, they are judgments about how you should live. I can make a very strong argument that the more a society acts like this, the more everyone is happy, including the rich and powerful, but that’s not why you should act that way, as powerful arguments can be made for selfish and destructive self-interest.  You should act that way because it’s the right thing to do, and you know it is, deep in your gut.

The problem in this sort of thinking comes with people who insist on acting selfish in ways that harms too many other people.  You can try the Martin Luther King, Jesus, Buddha or Gandhi approach with them: love them.  Try and help them.  And you should.  But sometimes that fails, as with Gandhi’s attempts with Hitler.

Then comes the time when force must be met with force, and evil met with evil.  And the question then is how not to become that which you fight, how to, in Christopher Dawson’s words, “not become indistinguishable from the evil (you) fight”.

It’s a hard question, and it’s one that many people have struggled with.  King acknowledged that the instinct to strike back violently was natural and he even acknowledged that not striking back had a psychological cost. Acting with love was medicine for the sickness of the white racist soul, and it had a cost for those who practiced it.  He also acknowledged that if non-violence didn’t work, violence was better than acceptance.

I will submit that the answer lies in red lines.  In actions you WILL NOT take no matter what.  No torture, for example.  No rape.  No deliberate degradation of other people.  When I hear those who believe in the greater good who want to torture other people, think prison rape is just or who like the idea of making other people crawl and beg, I know they have stared into the abyss too long.  They aren’t necessarily indistinguishable from the evil they fight, but they are walking that path.

At the same time, an insistence on complete moral purity is a road to evil of another kind, it is the road that leads to a man like Robespierre.  And a strange part of the route to this evil is a refusal to accept petty human failings (like adultery, for example).  A refusal to see that a person who has once done wrong, may still do much good.  A refusal to believe that those who have done evil, can be redeemed.

I will submit that what must not be tolerated is people who allow themselves to take pleasure in the pain or degradation of other people.  What was wrong with George Bush Jr. was that he was a sadist, a man who enjoyed other people’s pain. And worse, he was not sickened by his own sadism, but embraced it, and saw it as his right.

The men who voted to end segregation in the US included many racists.  They were racists who despised their own racism.  None of us are free of evil, none of us, but we are free to decided how we will act and we are free to embrace our evil or despise it.  We can’t always choose our evils, many are set while we are still young, others come out of the darker strands of human nature, but we are free to choose how we will react to our evil.

In this we come back to the maxim “if you aren’t good, just act good”.  Character and personality are built up in part by habit. Kindness, generosity, love, are habits as much as anything else.  Your mind is great at justifying whatever you do.  Do evil and it will justify it, do good and it will justify that, and over time you will become a better person inside your head, inside your soul.  Fake it till you make it.

Which leads to the matter of morals (how you act towards those you know) and ethics (how you act to those you don’t know).  A person’s morals are not their ethics. Every time I hear some American politicians going on about how much his family is the most important thing in his life, I think “oh, so you’ll put your family before your responsibilities to your job?  Towards the millions of people who you have a duty to?”  And many of them do.  Their families get jobs with donors, and those donors get bills passed, and the next thing you know millions of people have been hurt, because they put their family first.  Or they worry about having more money to take care of their family, or leave their children, and they make sure tax policy favors people in their tax bracket.  Or….

I don’t want a good family person at the cost of public service, and neither should you.  I want someone who works as many hours as it takes, does what is right for the country, not their family interests, who puts people they’ve never met first.  I want someone who is ethical, not moral.  If they’re having an affair with their secretary, like FDR did, I just don’t care, and neither should you, if they’re doing a good job for the country.

All of this isn’t consistent, and it isn’t all coherent, but it is, I think, true.  Live, love, fail, do it some more.


If you enjoyed this article, and want me to write more, please DONATE or SUBSCRIBE.

Again, the absolute inability to consider obvious solutions

The NYTimes on solutions to the scarcity of important drugs which are generic and thus of little interest to big pharma:

Beyond limited responses, like using the F.D.A.’s discretionary powers to expedite temporary imports of drugs that are sold overseas but not here, there are very few ways to ease the crisis. For the longer term, bipartisan bills in Congress would require drug makers to give the F.D.A. six months’ warning of problems that might disrupt supplies. For that to work, the penalties for noncompliance would need to be stiff.

Other proposals include a national stockpile of critically important drugs, incentives to encourage the manufacture of generic drugs, and broader powers and additional resources for the F.D.A. to head off looming shortages. Some, perhaps many, Congressional Republicans will inevitably oppose an expansion of the F.D.A.’s regulatory authority. This cannot and must not be a fight over ideology. For many Americans, it is a fight for their lives.

Why not either just have the government manufacture them, or force the firms to do it?  There are more than a few ways to do so, including the war powers, act, I’m not even going to bother going into detail.  This is an issue of will, not means.

We pretend our age is non-ideological, but it is so ideological it can’t even see its ideology.  FDR or any president through Nixon, at least, and their Congresses, would have understood how to solve such a problem.

People are dying, but our leaders value the idea that the government shouldn’t do anything the private sector might do far more than they do the lives of their citizens.

RIP, Jack Layton, Federal New Democratic Party Leader

If you haven’t heard, Jack died of cancer.  I only saw him in person once, at a Toronto council meeting back when he was a city councilor, but he impressed me at the time as one of only three councilors who showed decent respect to the citizens giving testimony.  I didn’t know then, and don’t know now, if it was savvy politics, genuine feeling, or both, but it felt like both.

Following politics closely, as I have, I have contempt for the majority of politicians, a contempt most of them have earned.  Jack Layton is one of the few I respected.  This is not because the NDP is the party in Canada whose ideology most closely approximates mine, I’ve had cordial contempt for most of the NDP’s federal leaders during my lifetime, it’s because Jack seemed to combine ability with a genuine calling to help people.  He seemed to want to do the right thing, for the right reasons.  That’s rare enough in everyday life, it’s beyond rare amongst experienced politicians.

Losing Layton is a big blow.  It’s common to say things like “Canada is at a crossroads”, but this really is an era of crisis, and one where countries will be making choices which will determine how prosperous, free and equitable they are for generations.  The current Conservative government is making choices which will cripple Canada economically, destroying much of what was built over the course of the 19th and 20th centuries, making us into nothing more than a country which subsists on resources, a position which will leave us very subject to shocks, and as the Conservatives are implementing it, will make us more and more unequal.

The Liberals are not, unfortunately, a credible option.  They, as with most “centrist” parties in the world today, simply want to go to hell on the slow road.  Electing the NDP, then, is our only chance.  They might not do the right things, but they are the only party which would even consider doing the right things.  And Layton was a strong leader and one whom many Canadians genuinely liked.  The nickname “Smiling Jack” started out derisive, but it became a term of affection.

I hope the NDP will elect another strong leader, and one with genuine beliefs he or she intends to put into action if elected Prime Minister.  In the past the NDP has had a tendency to elect weak leaders who are aesthetically pleasing to the party’s constituents.  Neither Canada nor the NDP can afford to make the leader a statement, the leader must be a leader, and must be able to lead the party effectively, both in the next election and as Prime Minister.

If there is an afterlife, I’m sure Jack’s still smiling.  May he smile on all of us.  I don’t normally offer condolences to public figure’s loved ones, but as Olivia Chow was one of the other three councilors in that Toronto council meeting all those years ago who impressed me, I offer her my best wishes.

Jack will be missed.  But the best thing we can do in Jack’s memory is to continue his work, and make sure that the next government is NDP, and that once in government it does the right things.

RIP Jack.  The torch has fallen from your hands, but you led us farther than any of us would have dreamed. It’s up to us now.  You’d say it always was, and be right, but the world is genuinely better for you having lived.  There is no higher praise, and few of your generation of politicians can say the same.

P.S. Layton may be the only Canadian politician in my lifetime who could say something like “Love is better than anger, hope is better than fear”, and have me believe he meant it.  Because he actually lived his life that way and tried to help others live their lives that way.  Honestly, he’s the first public figure who has died in my life where I’m actually sad.

The Next President of the US

Not that my track record on Presidential predictions is all that good, but I’m laying odds it’s Rick Perry.

Unbelievable disrespect to a black man in Britain

Watch.  Seriously, watch it.

It’s hard to know what to say, because what I’m thinking is unprintable.  Yeah, what a surprise that the riots occurred.  What a surprise.  And cracking down will make it worse, not better.  This isn’t even close to over, and it will never be over while men or women like that interviewer are in any position of influence or power. (h/t Feminist Philosophers.)

Update: a friend points out the social reasons behind the insistence that any explanation is an excuse and that anyone who “excuses” the rioters must be immediately asked if they condone the riots as if explaining is the same thing as condoning.

The insistence on not allowing an explanation reminds me of Obama refusing to “play the blame game” with reference to the Bush administration and the shutting down of discourse around the 9/11 attacks.  Any attempt to actually understand why something happened threaten the official narrative, and might cast blame blame on those in power.  That can’t be allowed, so no explanation is allowed, only condemnation.  (Ian note: Remember all the nonsense about how the 9/11 hijackers were cowards?  They were many bad things, they weren’t cowards.)

Page 460 of 532

Powered by WordPress & Theme by Anders Norén