Ian Welsh

The horizon is not so far as we can see, but as far as we can imagine

Why I’m pessimistic on health reform and the argument for doing it anyway

Yesterday Brett asked why I’ve become negative on health care reform when so many other bloggers aren’t.

Of course, it’s dangerous to speak for other bloggers, but I think the calculus which many are operating under is that if you get a bill with some sort of public option, and some sort of subsidies, some lives will be saved.  Something, in other words, is better than nothing. I also think that people need to believe.  Many bloggers worked really really hard to elect Obama, to get a House and Senate majority, and the that it can’t deliver on something so fundamentally important as making sure every American has the health care they need is something they just don’t want to believe.

Also most other bloggers are not fundamentally econobloggers and econobloggers who don’t buy the “TARP saved the universe” disillusionment started much earlier than for most other bloggers.   For me it started at TARP time when Obama pushed through Paulson’s highway robbery act  Then Obama hired Geithner and Summers as his key economic people.  So I started down the path of “no hope” a lot earlier than most bloggers.

I use the stimulus bill as my model for looking at healthcare.  As with the stimulus bill I think that the House draft bill is the high point.  I think this is the best bill we are going to see.  I think the Senate bill will be worse (Daniel reported last night, as I was writing, that the Senate bill probably won’t have a public option) and that it may well be worse than nothing even if a weak public option is in the bill. In particularly Medicare and Medicaid are being hit to pay for this, people will have deductibles on “non preventative” care (and maybe preventative by the time it gets through) and so on.  The Massachussets experience, which is the closest parallel, has not been good.

There is a counterargument, I made part of it the first day I wrote at OpenLeft.  The public option could drive out private insurance or at least drive costs lower.  Getting people into the system turns them into real patients and suddenly there are doctors and so on who don’t want to lose them, and that gives them a constituency, and above all, you do save some lives and help some people and isn’t that better than nothing?

I’m not a single payor purist, though I think the fact single payer isn’t even on the table is a terrible indictment of the system—however, I’ll settle for a good public option, or even a non-sucky one.  But I’m becoming convinced that any public option will either be too compromised, or non existent, and at that point, all that happens is you have slashes to Medicare and Medicaid, forced purchase of bad insurance, and through those purchases more money being pumped into the system.

Is forcing people to buy insurance the real goal?  The best way to make money, bar none, is to have government force people to buy your product.  It’s a wet dream for any industry, so if it’s going to be done, it has to be done right—it has to be very highly regulated and controlled with rates of return set like utilities.

Will it be?

(Addendum: Before I ride off into the sunset next thursday, I’ll see if I can pull together a post on what is required for a good public option.  One of the reasons I favor single payor is that it has many fewer moving parts. It’s easier to do single payor right than it is to do a public option right.  Not least because there are many different working models of single payer and variations.  Getting the public option right is very complicated.)

How stupid do they think we are? (Executive Compensation edition)

Seriously, can’t Obama even pretend he intends to meaningfully reform corporate governance?  If not, why does he insult our intelligence? (h/t Americablog)

The president specifically mentioned regulatory changes that would require shareholders to have nonbinding votes on executive compensation packages (emphasis added)

This is similar to the plan to create create standardized credit default swaps (CDSs) which can trade on open markets, but not require firms to actually use them, and still allow custom CDSs.

I’d say that Obama and his financial advisors still think that if they just ask banks and brokers nicely, they’ll do the right thing, but that would insult the administration’s intelligence as well as mine and yours.

Why health care reform isn’t: part II-the bought and paid for Congress

He who has the gold, makes the rules

The numbers on how much various medical interests have spent on influencing Congress and the Presidency make clear why health care reform keeps getting watered down:

..the data so far suggest that the second quarter has a good chance of reaching a new high for the health-care lobby. The industry already set records from January to March, when health-care firms and their lobbyists spent money at the rate of $1.4 million a day.

Impressive…  Is anyone on the side of good reform spending that type of money?

Of course they aren’t.  Healthcare in the US costs 5% more of GDP than it should.  That’s a lot of money, and there are a lot of people getting rich off that money.  They’ll do whatever they have to in order to keep the flow coming.  When you’re talking 692 billion dollars (give or take), well, what’s 1.2 million a day to keep the cash flow coming?

The fundamental truth of America’s Congress is that its first and most important function, when you take the time to look at the bills it passes, is to take money from rich special interests and then pass bills which favor them.  The same, I’m afraid, is true of the presidency.  Most of the 15 trillion given, loaned and guaranteed during the financial crisis was to the financial sector, and most of that was given by the Federal Reserve, which if it answers to anyone (questionable) answers to the President.  But even when Congress got into play it’s noticeable that they gave 700 billion for TARP but are now insisting that health reform be “decifit neutral”.  Likewise no one seems to mind giving lots of money to the military.

Interesting set of priorities.  Politicians seem to always be telling us how “protecting Americans” is their most important duty.  Which is how they justify spending money on a military which doesn’t seem to protect Americans from anything noticeable.  And by protecting I assume they mean “save American lives.”  This is odd, because health reform, properly done, would save those lives than anything else except massive reform of the way Ameiricans eat. But, unlike with the military, there isn’t a health-reform complex pushing to save American lives that is nearly as strong as the one pushing to keep the gravy train going.  So suddenly, saving American lives isn’t a priority.

The Gates Conundrum: Racism or Police “Authority”

Whenever I read about an incident such as the one which happened with Henry Louis Gates Jr, in which a police officer arrests someone for, essentially, not paying them enough respect, the old Cartman line “respect my authoritae!” floats through my mind.

After reading the officer’s account and Gates account, I have no idea whether racism was at the core of Gates being arrested. But I will lay long odds that if Gates had done everything Sergeant Crowley had told him to do and done it snappish, well, he wouldn’t have been arrested. My interactions with police in the US have all reinforced to me that even something as simple as a question is interpreted by many policy as a direct assault on their authority, and that they have no tolerance for any such thing. If a policeman in the US asks you to do something, or tells you, you’d best do it, right now, whether he has the right to order you around or not. And if you don’t, be ready to deal with the consequences.

Which is to say, I agree with lawyer Scott Greenfield, when he writes:

But there is similarly a possibility, based upon a larger experience by those who follow the conduct of police officers, that this was unrelated to Henry Louis Gates’ race.  This encounter could have, and has, happened to whites as well as black, to Hispanics as well as Asians.  To old women and young men.

Henry Louis Gates was arrested for engaging in “tumultuous” behavior.  Only in Cambridge would the complaint use the word “tumultuous”.  But many a man forced from his castle upon the command of a police officer who refused to accept that he was at home would have been outraged.  Tumult seems an appropriate way to act.  The crime was Gates’ hurling words at Sgt. Crowley at a time when the sergeant commanded him to be obsequious and compliant.  Gates would not calm down.  There is no law that requires him to be calm because a police officer ordered him to do so.  Other than the expectation that we do what an officer tells us to do, no matter what.

It may well be that what happened to Henry Louis Gates reflects, as he is accused of screaming at Sgt. Crowley, “what happens to a black man in America.”  Because the black man happens to be the director of the W.E.B. Du Bois Institute for African and African American Research at Harvard, perhaps the pre-eminent black scholar, it will open a discussion that we still need to have, black president notwithstanding.

It is also possible, however, that what happened to Henry Louis Gates is the outgrowth of the conflict between law and order, order represented by police who have been empowered, in our post 9/11 age, to believe that their every command is the law, that our blind obedience is mandatory.  Other than a few old-timers on the Supreme Court who live in a fantasy world where ordinary people can assert their rights and refuse to comply with the command of a police officer with impunity, this encounter between a distinguished scholar, within his own home, and a police sergeant who believes that his command is sufficient to create the divide between citizen and criminal, may offer the chance to question who commands whom in our society.

The counter to this is that “cops everywhere are cops”.  Now there’s certainly some truth to that.  But I will say this.  I don’t fear Canadian police the way I do American ones.  My sample size isn’t large, but I’ve found that unless there’s a real crisis or threat (ie. not an unarmed 60 year old man), most of them don’t demand instant obseqious obedience to their every demand and are willing to answer reasonable questions.

In the US my experience has been that unless I want things to get unpleasant, I’d better click my heels, cringe and do as commanded.

So, racism?  I don’t know.  Could well be.  But I don’t think it’s necessary to invoke racism to explain officer Crowley’s behaviour.  He was disrespected by someone who didn’t obey his every command.  To his mind he was even lenient, he gave his orders multiple times.  Gates stepped out of line and needed to be put in his place, not because he was black, but because he was a civilian who wasn’t doing what a police officer told him.

The real dividing line may not be black and white, the real dividing line may be the blue line.  You either wear the blue, or you don’t, and Gates didn’t.

(Addendum: I read the police report when it was released.  When I went looking for it today, it had been taken down both by the Boston Globe and the NY Daily News.  How… interesting.  Fortunately someone saved a copy. I’m so glad the press has an adversarial relationship with authority.)

The Compromised President and Congress: Why this health care bill probably won’t reduce costs

Ok, I’ve tried to keep an open mind on this. I prefer single payor, but a properly done public option could, indeed, drive down costs and help some people get care.

But I’m no longer sure I can maintain benefit of the doubt.  First it was the AMA endorsement, which was bought by a promise not to reduce medicare rates as much as initially planned.  Now I read from Robert Reich that the price of pharma not killing it is:

  • Not allowing drug reimportation from Canada
  • Not allowing the government to negotiate drug prices

The 80 billion pharma promised last month is a small price to pay for that, and I’ll tell you right now that that 80 billion won’t appear anyway.  As soon as the pharma companies can betray, they will.

The mandate, as Reich points out, can easily lead to insurance companies earning more money than they’ll lose, which since the insurance companies are the problem, means that costs won’t go down much, if at all.

All in all, I don’t think any bill that’s going to come out of this Congress is going to be strong enough to drive down costs or even significantly reduce the growth rate.  The mandates, combined with insufficient subsidies mean that many people are going to be hurt by being forced to buy insurance.  The Massachussets plan, which this is based on, has not worked well.  This isn’t going to either.

This bill is turning into a pork-fest.  Buy-in is being achieved by making it clear that stakeholders will make more money once it’s done, not less.

My biggest weakness this year in doing analysis has been hope.  I have let hope that the Obama administration and a Democratic Congress will do the right thing, and that they aren’t corrupt and incompetent, get in the way of clear thinking.  Enough.  Hope isn’t a plan, and hope isn’t policy.  Hope without good policy is a con-job.

There hasn’t been a good, major, bill come out of this Congress this year.  They have all been fatally compromised, from the stimulus bill (larded up with useless tax cuts and without necessary State relief) to the global warming bill, which is so far from doing enough that it’s a joke.

At this point I see no reason to believe this bill won’t be the same.  Yes, a few people may get health care who wouldn’t otherwise and that matters, but it won’t contain costs to any significant degree and it will put a huge burden on Americans who can’t afford it.  The likelihood that a surtax on the rich to pay for it won’t happen just makes this even more clear.

This is not the Bush administration, but the primary assumption of the Bush years that nothing would get through Congress that wasn’t bought and paid for; that wasn’t fatally compromised at very best still holds in only a mildly mitigated form.  Yes, Obama and the Democrats sometimes try to do the right thing while Bush almost never bothered, but  the bills that come out at the end are still awful.

This year is effectively over.  Obama’s ratings are dropping and will continue to drop as the economy doesn’t improve for ordinary people.  In future years he will reap what he has sown: bad policy will lead to bad real results, and Obama and the Democratic Congress will be blamed for that.  They will deserve it.

Hope I’m wrong about this.

But I wouldn’t bet on it.  Even hope wears thin over time.

Bottom Line On the Financial Sector: fewer bigger companies and a repeat of the financial crisis

I think the obvious needs to be pointed out: after this crisis is over, there will be fewer large financial firms who control a larger percentage of the business. There will be less large (and small) banks and less brokers. The market will be closer to an oligopoly, and those involved in it, even if they don’t formally collude, will take advantage of their market power to increase their profits. It’s already happening, as (amusingly) BlackRock founder Fink pointed out:

Larry Fink, BlackRock’s founder and chief executive, on Tuesday took aim at the “luxurious” trading profits enjoyed by Wall Street banks, saying that they have taken advantage of reduced competition to charge their customers more for even basic trades.

“There are fewer players. There is very little capital being committed by these dealers,” Mr Fink said.

“They’re just taking the spread between the bid and the ask [the price gap between buyers and sellers] and they are making very luxurious returns,” he added.

It is hard to feel Blackrock’s pain, of course, but increased bid/ask spreads and increased fees aren’t in the interest of market liquidity or efficiency.  It is, in the purest sense, rent-taking (getting money for your position in a system, rather than for making the system better).

It is basic economic theory that the fewer actors in a sector of a private market (I won’t call it a free market, it isn’t) the worse for customers an the more the actors will be able to squeeze out oligopoly profits simply because of their position.

This is also something that every Congressperson and pundit who ever squeals about “competition” should find ominous—fewer and fewer firms competing in what is America’s most important sector.  (It must be America’s most important sector because America has spent going on 14 trillion defending it.)

Add to this that the appetite for risky credit default swaps has recovered and there is no move to ban or significantly regulate them; that firms like Goldman Sachs are back to their old ways; and that the ratings agencies have escaped any significant overhaul and it becomes a virtual certainty that the financial disaster we are going through was only the first.  The system is now more concentrated and more unstable than it was before.  The market actors are even larger than they were before: even more “too big to fail”.

When the horse bolts the barn and you refuse to even close the door after you’ve put it back in the barn, it becomes clear that you have no intention to stop it from happening again.  That’s what Washington’s actions tell us.  They truly believe this was a one off affair, that no one could have anticipated (because Summers and Geithner sure didn’t anticipate it, and they are sure they are the smartest people around) so therefore there’s no need to make real systematic changes.  All that is required are some minor regulatory changes and to give primary responsibility to the Federal Reserve, they not only failed to stop the last disaster but enabled it to occur and since of all regulatory agencies they are the most removed from Congressional control.

Welcome to your future.  It is going to look a lot like the present and the recent past.

Insurers engaged in systematic price fixing

This is a story I had missed.  It seems that insurance companies determined rates for “out of network” medical services by looking at an independent database run by a company called Ingenix, United Health Group.

But the way the database “independently” determined the going rate was by having insurance companies enter data on how much the rate was for given services.  And for a decade they systematically entered prices which were lower than the actual prices being charged by doctors.

The result was that patients would get a larger bill than expected, the insurance companies would redeem the doctors for less than expected, and often the gap would never be made up.  A win for insurance companies, a loss for patients and doctors.

Companies involved, include (but I’m not sure if are limited to):

United, WellPoint, Aetna, Cigna, GHI/HIP, Capital District Physicians’ Health Plan, Independent Health, Excellus, MVP Health Care, HealthNow and Guardian Life Insurance Co

They have all “settled” with NY Attorney General Andrew Cuomo’s office and promised to use a new, more transparent database as soon as one is available.  They have given 100 million to make the new database.  And, of course, none have admitted they did anything wrong.

Bottom line on this is that the amount of money they saved (ripped off) is almost certainly more than their “settlements”.  So the entire scheme has been worth it, especially since no one went to jail.  Just another cost of doing business.

This is how large american corporations operate.  Law breaking and immoral behaviour is simply a cost-benefit matter.  If the money saved by doing something illegal is more than the cost of doing something illegal (including legal costs), too many of them will do it.

I would suggest that the only things which would really get executives to stop doing these sorts of things are to either treat them as criminal matters (and send CEOs to jail) or to treat them as what they are: clear collusive action to use an oligopoly position to control prices, and break them up.  But the second is no longer possible after the Supreme Court ruled that actions which suggest collusion cannot be taken as evidence of collusion, overturning prior precdent.

And, of course, senior executives rarely go to jail for screwing ordinary people, let alone committing massive fraud (or half Wall Street would be heading for the hoosegow) so real criminal charges certainly won’t happen.

I wonder what other scams the insurance companies are running we don’t know about?  What other ways they are fixing the books?  Only a fool would bet they aren’t.

Insurers engaged in systematic price fixing

This is a story I had missed.  It seems that insurance companies determined rates for “out of network” medical services by looking at an independent database run by a company called Ingenix, United Health Group.

But the way the database “independently” determined the going rate was by having insurance companies enter data on how much the rate was for given services.  And for a decade they systematically entered prices which were lower than the actual prices being charged by doctors.

The result was that patients would get a larger bill than expected, the insurance companies would redeem the doctors for less than expected, and often the gap would never be made up.  A win for insurance companies, a loss for patients and doctors.

Companies involved, include (but I’m not sure if are limited to):

United, WellPoint, Aetna, Cigna, GHI/HIP, Capital District Physicians’ Health Plan, Independent Health, Excellus, MVP Health Care, HealthNow and Guardian Life Insurance Co

They have all “settled” with NY Attorney General Andrew Cuomo’s office and promised to use a new, more transparent database as soon as one is available.  They have given 100 million to make the new database.  And, of course, none have admitted they did anything wrong.

Bottom line on this is that the amount of money they saved (ripped off) is almost certainly more than their “settlements”.  So the entire scheme has been worth it, especially since no one went to jail.  Just another cost of doing business.

This is how large american corporations operate.  Law breaking and immoral behaviour is simply a cost-benefit matter.  If the money saved by doing something illegal is more than the cost of doing something illegal (including legal costs), too many of them will do it.

I would suggest that the only things which would really get executives to stop doing these sorts of things are to either treat them as criminal matters (and send CEOs to jail) or to treat them as what they are: clear collusive action to use an oligopoly position to control prices, and break them up.  But the second is no longer possible after the Supreme Court ruled that actions which suggest collusion cannot be taken as evidence of collusion, overturning prior precdent.

And, of course, senior executives rarely go to jail for screwing ordinary people, let alone committing massive fraud (or half Wall Street would be heading for the hoosegow) so real criminal charges certainly won’t happen.

I wonder what other scams the insurance companies are running we don’t know about?  What other ways they are fixing the books?  Only a fool would bet they aren’t.

Page 518 of 532

Powered by WordPress & Theme by Anders Norén