Peter Daou wants to know if this is the best the US can do (h/t Digby):
A calamity is unfolding before our eyes – the greatest oil spill in history – and America’s response is little more than a big yawn.
The vast, sprawling coastal marshes of Louisiana, where the Mississippi River drains into the gulf, are among the finest natural resources to be found anywhere in the world. And they are a positively crucial resource for America. The response of the Obama administration and the general public to this latest outrage at the hands of a giant, politically connected corporation has been embarrassingly tepid. … This is the bitter reality of the American present, a period in which big business has cemented an unholy alliance with big government against the interests of ordinary Americans, who, of course, are the great majority of Americans. The great majority of Americans no longer matter. America is selling its soul for oil. – Bob Herbert
Where is the outrage? Where are the millions marching in the streets, where is the round-the-clock roadblock coverage tracking every moment of the crisis, every effort to plug the leak, every desperate attempt to mitigate the damage?
Where is the White House? Where are Republicans? Where are Democrats? Where is the left? Where is the right? Where is the “fierce urgency of now?”
Prominent oceanographers [are] accusing the government of failing to conduct an adequate scientific analysis of the damage and of allowing BP to obscure the spill’s true scope. The scientists assert that the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration and other agencies have been slow to investigate the magnitude of the spill and the damage it is causing in the deep ocean. – NYT
In the movies, pretend heroes like Bruce Willis and Will Smith save the planet while the whole world watches with breath and belief suspended. In real life, a global catastrophe is treated like a mere annoyance, mismanaged by a rapacious oil company, while drill-baby-drillers double down on their folly and the White House puts out defensive fact sheets about how they were on it from “day one.”
In some parts of the country, the sight of oil drifting toward the Louisiana coast, oozing into the fragile marshlands and bringing large parts of the state’s economy to a halt, has prompted calls to stop offshore drilling indefinitely, if not altogether. Here, in the middle of things, those calls are few. Here, in fact, the unfolding disaster is not even prompting a reconsideration of the 75th annual Louisiana Shrimp and Petroleum Festival. “All systems are go,” said Lee Delaune, the festival’s director, sitting in his cluttered office in a historic house known as Cypress Manor. “We will honor the two industries as we always do,” Mr. Delaune said. “More so probably in grand style, because it’s our diamond jubilee.” – NYT
Is this really the best we can do?
Yes, it pretty much is, Peter. First, this shows the fundamental continuity between Bush and Obama. The reaction to this is fundamentally the same as the reaction to Katrina and New Orleans: do the least possible, and sweep it under the rug as best you can. Does anyone imagine the Bush administration’s response to this disaster would have been fundamentally different from Obama’s? Or rather, does anyone think that Obama has treated this more seriously than Bush would have?
But Daou’s point is broader than this, he blames everyone. The left, the right, both parties, the public. The outrage over this doesn’t seem to be there, the demands for action are tepid.
I think this comes back to something about Americans I’ve witnessed over and over again. Many Americans, if something doesn’t directly affect them, think it doesn’t matter enough to get worked up over. There is this weird sense of “we’ll be fine and who cares about what’s happening to someone I don’t know?” Americans can’t really imagine disaster, or catastrophe, unless it happens to them or someone they’re close to. Otherwise, it’s all just “something on TV”, and fundamentally unreal to them.
So they don’t connect the dots. They don’t get what wiping out all this sea life, destroying beaches and marshlands, is going to do to them. (Among other things, dying wetlands means more likelihood of Katrina style disasters). Of course some of them do care and do connect the dots, but believe that there’s nothing they can do. After all, millions protested the Iraq war and it didn’t matter. Americans voted in Democrats in 2006 to end the Iraq war, and it didn’t happen. Americans called 19/1 against TARP and it passed. Americans voted in Obama to get real change, and he decided to be Bush #2.
I think it’s probably a bit of both: some folks just don’t see how it affects them and don’t care about things that affect other Americans, while other folks care or understand, but feel that there’s nothing they can do about it, since government is almost entirely unresponsive to their concerns, so why waste time getting worked up?
This is America, Peter. The best suffer from learned helplessness, the worst just don’t care unless they’re the ones being hurt.

