Ian Welsh

The horizon is not so far as we can see, but as far as we can imagine

The True Panopticon Will Read Your Thoughts

We have this view of the big nasty surveillance state which was set by the novel 1984. But 1984’s technology was primitive: Big Brother couldn’t record, for example, so if no one was watching a monitor while you did whatever Big Brother didn’t like, you got away with it.

But Big Brother had nothing on what is coming down the line. In China, businesses are already making their employees wear caps which measure brainwaves, and they will move you about or even send you home based on your brainwaves. It’s not all bad; if an air traffic controller’s brain waves went into a pattern which showed lack of concentration ability, for example, they would remove that controller.

MIT has recently announced a headset which can read speech we didn’t actually say:

MIT researchers have developed a headset that can identify words you think of but don’t actually say, by reading signals the brain sends to the face and jaw during internal speech.

The AlterEgo headset captures the neuromuscular signals that occur when people intend to speak. It then uses a neural network to reconstruct the word.

This isn’t the same as reading thoughts, but a lot thoughts we would never say do hit that neuromuscular network, then get inhibited. We’ve all had the experience of “biting our tongue” — carefully keeping things we really want to say to ourselves.

This is still early days, and these are early and crude technologies. We know that the part of our brain which is aware and which considers us tends to be behind the times: The decision to do something is made before we are aware of it, we then back-fill with justifications for decisions we already made.

We can tell that, and in time we will be able to tell that with cheap, mobile equipment, and I am reasonably sure we will be able to tell in advance what the decisions are. We will be able to read intention, and read thoughts that don’t get to the face and jaw, even.

I trust the implications for freedom are obvious.

And this is all before we get to behavioural modification. We’re better at this than we think we are right now, through the mode of gamification, used by terribly addictive social media websites like Facebook and Twitter; but we’re terrible at it in the nitty-gritty of neurons and neurotransmitters and so on, because it’s so complicated.

Still, in time, we will be able to directly manipulate the brain and body to produce emotions and even thoughts on demand as well as to inhibit them. We’ll be able to make people like, hate, love, or fear, and do it directly.

This will have vast therapeutic value, to be sure. It could create a heaven. But such direct control over individuals will be abused, and it will almost certainly be abused at scale, over entire societies.

Because it is control, and people with power (this doesn’t just mean governments) always want more control, and always use it unless forced not to.


The results of the work I do, like this article, are free, but food isn’t, so if you value my work, please DONATE or SUBSCRIBE.

Trump Pulls Out of the Iran Deal

Yeah, so, it was a good deal and one of the very few real accomplishments of Obama’s foreign policy, possible only after Clinton was no longer Secretary of State.

The fear here is that this is part of a march to war against Iran, something many in the Republican party want, and something pushed hard by Israel and Saudi Arabia.

This was the danger of Republican win: Clinton was deranged about Syria, Trump is deranged about Iran. Both are allies of Russia, and Russia will not want to allow Iran to be destroyed by an American coalition. While the risk of a confrontation between the US and Russia is not as severe over Iran as it was over Syria, it is still very real.

Plus, of course, the Iranians don’t have nuclear weapons and just making enriched uranium didn’t mean they wanted nuclear weapons.

Fortunately, the Europeans are pushing back hard against this, and are willing to just cut their own deal. That may help somewhat.


The results of the work I do, like this article, are free, but food isn’t, so if you value my work, please DONATE or SUBSCRIBE.

Further Reading: May 8, 2018

More pieces worth reading.

An Israeli private intelligence firm tried to gather compromising information on Obama officials behind the Iran nuclear deal. Lots of people want that deal dead, and a nice little war.

In the last two years, half the Great Barrier Reef has died.

“You like to breathe?” Crosby asked. “Estimates are that up to 80 percent of the oxygen you are breathing in right now comes from the ocean. It doesn’t come from the land. In order for you to continue to breathe, you have to have a healthy ocean.”

Might be that this matters. Coral die-offs correlate to great die-offs, and in the past, no apex predator has ever survived a great die-off. (A commenter pointed this out, but I do not remember who, my apologies.)

Civil forfeiture, where police take money or another asset, even though no crime has ever been proved, now takes more from Americans than robbery. This piece on how customs and borders took forty-one thousand from an American (she sued to get it back, and will eventually) includes a lot of interesting background.

This short piece at Emptywheel, by Ed Walker, talks about the political gift economy: How corporations and rich people give politicians gifts; politicians enact legislation or policies favorable to the rich, and everyone pretends there is no actual exchange going on.

This older news piece talks about how Britain’s spies are to use social media to disrupt “misinformation”. Do I have to say how much asking spies to decide what is misinformation or not seems dubious and anti-democratic?

What are you reading that other people should read? Tell us in the comments.


The results of the work I do, like this article, are free, but food isn’t, so if you value my work, please DONATE or SUBSCRIBE.

Will Children Ever Be Free Again?

So, apparently in Japan, children as young as six and seven travel alone:

It’s a common sight on Japanese mass transit: Children troop through train cars, singly or in small groups, looking for seats.

They wear knee socks, polished patent leather shoes, and plaid jumpers, with wide-brimmed hats fastened under the chin and train passes pinned to their backpacks. The kids are as young as six or seven, on their way to and from school, and there is nary a guardian in sight.

Oh my, what an exotic sight.

So exotic, that in the 70s and early 80s in Vancouver, Canada, I saw it all the time. Heck, I was one of those kids. At that age, I would take myself from my home down to the YMCA for gymnastics classes and I would take myself to school, either using the bus or just walking. It never occurred to me or my parents that I should do otherwise, or that I couldn’t do it.

I remember moving to Vancouver at age six or so, and exploring the city and the beach, downtown, by myself.

And I can tell you that there were some pretty seedy parts of Vancouver. It was heroin city back then, too.

I spent my days doing what I wanted once school was out, and I was responsible only for being home at meal times and bed time. My parents had only the vaguest idea where I was or what I was doing. “Going out to play” included a multi-block radius.

Here’s the truth: Most adults can be trusted and will look out for small children. Further, most of the time small children don’t need it; they are more capable than modern Westerners think they are. I cast back, thinking of times I needed the help of strangers. I can remember only two, and both times it was given unstintingly and without my even asking.

We are a paranoid bunch of ninnies. There is, actually, less violence now (though perhaps it is because we keep them in a closet and throw away the key) than there was in the past, and most danger is almost entirely from people they know. It is not some nasty stranger who will hurt your child: It is Uncle Bob, or a teacher, coach, or neighbour you trust.

The rare exceptions are exceptions, and the press makes a big deal of them for exactly that reason. “Man bites dog,” not “Dog bites man.”

Of course, mores have changed. Let your kid run free like the children of my childhood did and someone will probably call the cops.

Ninnies indeed. And I see the results when I deal with children in their late teens and early twenties. They are far more uncertain, more scared, than my cohort was at the same age. This isn’t their fault, they were never given freedom, never allowed to fail and succeed on their own terms–never expected to take care of themselves.

Doubtless this will change again, as we move into the era of ultra-surveillance, the panopticon police state. But I fear children will never again be free.


The results of the work I do, like this article, are free, but food isn’t, so if you value my work, please DONATE or SUBSCRIBE.

 

Further Reading: May 4, 2018

Once again, articles I’ve been reading which you might wish to as well.

First, the Canadian experience with public/private partnerships building schools.

Even the KPMG Value for Money report on the Saskatchewan P3 schools shows the traditional build model is less expensive on all accounts (construction, procurement, financing). The one exception is KPMG’s addition of $150.4 million in “retained risks” slapped onto the cost of the traditional build model. These “risks” are not actual costs incurred, but rather an imaginary number pulled out of the air. It is only because of these theoretical risks the government claims the P3 model is cheaper.

We can look to other provinces for more evidence P3s are costlier. In 2014, the Conservative government of Alberta cancelled plans to build 14 schools with the P3 model to save $14 million. The New Brunswick auditor general found two P3 schools cost $1.7 million more than publicly delivered and maintained schools. In 2014, Ontario’s auditor general reviewed 74 P3 projects and found there was “no empirical data” to support the P3 model, and that they cost $8 billion more than if they had been publicly financed and operated.

Well, ouch. But remember, the private sector is always more efficient!

Seems farmland bird populations in France have dropped by a third over the past fifteen years due to pesticides and intensive farming, and the rate of loss is speeding up. Biologists are warning of the land turning into dessert. Ha! Our politicians and biotech firms would never allow or do such a thing!

It seems that the fascist right in the US has, for the moment, basically been crushed. (And punched, rather a lot.) A detailed state of play.

And in your “Peons? Who needs peons?” news, the Chinese military is testing unmanned tanks. Apparently they may start testing AI driven tanks soon. While I rather don’t expect Skynet, the less our lords and masters need humans as enforcers, the less chance they will be overthrown if they get (even more) out of hand. But, hey, I’m sure it’ll be okay. They’d never use that stuff on their own citizens or in aggressive war.

Well, that’s what I’ve been reading. What have you been reading that you think others should read as well?


The results of the work I do, like this article, are free, but food isn’t, so if you value my work, please DONATE or SUBSCRIBE.

Remember the Past & Captain Kirk Accurately

I recently read an excellent, long article about how the popular conception of Captain Kirk in the original Star Trek series is all wrong. He never slept with a green woman, or even slept around: He was not a womanizer. His relationship history is reasonable and shows no pattern of abuse, not even emotional abuse. He wasn’t a maverick who didn’t obey orders or a jerk. He was competent, and even an intellectual, and the most important thing to him was his ship and the safety of the people on board it, not personal glory or any such thing.

We have weird ideas about history. A lot of it comes down either seeing the present as better, or worse, than it is.  We think we’re all better than the late 60s and early 70s when it comes to gender relations, for example, so we assume that Kirk was bad that way.

But, in fact, the conception of masculinity that we have in male movie leads today is completely foreign to that time. Even the “action” leads don’t look body builders, and, except in martial arts movies, they can’t win fights against lots of other guys, and so on. They aren’t power fantasies, in part probably because so many guys had been in real brawls and fought in wars.

Even the Dirty Harry movies show Callahan as very much not super-human. He isn’t an action hero as we typically define them: He can’t take on large numbers of “mooks.” He wins at least one iconic fight simply by outsmarting his opponent who drowns by being unable to stop his motorcycle from sliding into the ocean.

This is not to say that there wasn’t plenty of bad masculinity around then: There was a lot of wife-beating, for example. There was a lot more actual violence, period. But it was far less glamorized than we make ours–there was little pretense that it was pretty.

And it didn’t involve men with big muscles; that wasn’t the masculine archetype. Even John Wayne, while big, was not a body builder.

We have images of the past that are archetypes, and those archetypes aren’t necessarily right. The whole incel thing is unimaginable from a 70s perspective. Whatever has gone wrong with men in our era is not what was wrong with men in the 70s. We have actual different pathologies and in some ways (not all) they are worse.

Certainly we are less free in many ways than the 60s and early 70s were. It isn’t even a question: You could walk into almost any non-military building back then with no security. There were less cameras. Credit scores and drug tests were far less common. More drugs were legal.

In other ways we are more free, especially in terms of sex.

We use the past to justify the present, and to argue for our preferred futures. We caricature it, pick out highlights, and so on.

Some of this is inevitable, but it’s wise to at least know what we’re doing. And when the actual original resources are available, we should respect them. The movies and the TV shows of that era still exist. In many cases, we can easily still see them.

It was not “every thus” that TV was a sexist wasteland. In fact, Star Trek was a utopian show, trying to show a world in which gender and race mattered less than it does today, but where it still did matter (one of Kirk’s ex’s broke up with him because she hated that as a white male he got preference).

It wasn’t a dinosaur show that was evil–it was better than many shows are today. And Kirk wasn’t Don Draper sitting in the captain’s chair. He was a far, far better man.

Anyway, read the article. It’s important beyond the specifics of the case, but it’s also a good read.


The results of the work I do, like this article, are free, but food isn’t, so if you value my work, please DONATE or SUBSCRIBE.

Further Reading: May 3, 2018

So, for a long time I’ve kept track of interesting stuff I should write about.

And not written about most of it.

So the plan is a series of “Further Reading” posts in which I give brief commentary and links to stuff I think is, well, worth reading. (Er, and also some tweets and graphics and maybe songs or podcasts and so on.)

Inaugural edition, ahoy!

Let’s start with a nice graphic showing up the creek we are on climate change with respect to changing what energy we use. Could write a post on that but I may have already a few times this year. *cough*

Amazon is a shit place to work and Jeff Bezos is not a nice person to his employees, edition “carry bottles to pee in because you have no time to do so if you work at Amazon.”

Could be I spend a bit too much time on twitter, but this little graphic on whether Brits want to rejoin the EU after leaving is worth viewing.

The world bank is the less sucky of the IMF and World Bank pair. I say this to provide context to the fact the World Bank is recommending countries scrap minimum wage laws.

And a bit old, but the Gulf Stream system is slowing down much faster than projected due to climate change. That’s the thing that keeps Europe warmer than it should be, and also, if it slows down too much, East coast North American storms will be much worse. Fun.

What have you been reading, listening to, etc… that you think is worth people’s attention?


The results of the work I do, like this article, are free, but food isn’t, so if you value my work, please DONATE or SUBSCRIBE.

Most “High Performers” Are Just Better Parasites

Most so-called high performers are just excellent parasites. Amazon pays no tax and many of their employees are on food stamps and welfare. Walmart encourages its workers to go on food stamps, while it guts municipal tax bases. Apple actively avoids taxes and both Apple and Microsoft built their entire business on technology they stole from Xerox. Microsoft, in particular, built their business on monopolistic practices that would have led to the breakup of the company if Bush’s administration hadn’t interfered.

The asshole “high performers” in the financial industry required a many trillion dollar bailout. They should have all gone bankrupt and most of them should have gone to jail. They threw much of the world into an economic crisis which has still not ended. They are high performance ticks (leeches have benefits, they are very close to pure negatives.) The oil industry receives massive subsidies, and so on and so forth.

Studies show that consumption of social media correlates with decreased well-being and unhappiness, and the more you consume the worse it is. The evidence for this is overwhelming. They do it with less employment than prior industries and pay less taxes. This is not the behavior of a symbiote, it is the behavior of a parasite.

The simple FACT is that during the 50s and 60s, when high earners (whom fools seem to think are the same as high performers) were massively taxed the economy did far better.

All other things held equal, it is relative equality (not absolute, do not straw man) that makes for better economies and societies.

(The data on this is not even slightly ambiguous, read “The Spirit Level” to see it nailed in place in tedious but apparently necessary detail.)

If this economy is what the “high performers” produce, I’ll go back to one run by the mediocre people, thanks.


The results of the work I do, like this article, are free, but food isn’t, so if you value my work, please DONATE or SUBSCRIBE.

Page 328 of 532

Powered by WordPress & Theme by Anders Norén