Ian Welsh

The horizon is not so far as we can see, but as far as we can imagine

Corrected: Support for Public Option (Does Not) Collapse If Real Public Option Polled

winged_caduceus

Edit: oops.  I’m full of it.  Misread the poll.  In fact it indicates the opposite of my title.  Ignore the below.  Perhaps the public option will be fantastically popular.

The problem with public option polling is that the questions imply strongly that everyone has access to it.  In fact, most people don’t have access to it (if, for example, your employer offers insurance you can’t opt out and go to the public option.)  Kip Sullivan did a bit of investigating and found a poll which actually did inform Americans of this fact (h/t Corrente):

“Would you support or oppose having the government create a new health insurance plan to compete with private health insurance plans?”
Support: 55%
Oppose:42%
Unsure: 3%

If oppose/unsure: “What if this government-sponsored plan was available only to people who cannot get health insurance from a private insurer? In that case, would you support or oppose it?”
Support: 21%
Oppose: 24%

That’s quite the difference, don’t you think?  As I noted in my last post, voters are going to be furious with Democrats if they pass any of the current proposed health care “reform” bills. The public option in all of them is crippled and the subsidies are low, such that they will eat as much as 1/3 to a half of many people’s disposable income.

Because the public option proposed in any of these bills is not robust, since they won’t have enough enrollment to have market pricing power, and thus won’t be able to force down costs, there is no reason to believe that health care reform will actually contain health cost increases below inflation, let alone below wage increases.

Since the bills also force people to buy insurance, that means voters will be forced to buy insurance whose cost will rise faster than their wages.  This is particular pernicious when it comes to 20 and 30-somethings, fresh out of College, with huge student loans already, and few good job prospects.

This is horrible policy. It is also political suicide.  The people in the progressive blogosphere who are pushing for a “public option” without insisting on an actual robust option (again, none of the options being considered are robust and even if linked to Medicare rates none of them will be because they are not large enough) are pushing for a law which is a massive giveaway to insurance companies—a regressive tax on the middle class.  It is worse than immoral, though it’s terribly immoral, it is a horrible mistake the price for which will be paid at the ballot box.

I have warned on this repeatedly, as have others.  We have not been listened to.  I am not looking forward to having the last laugh on this, because it is a laugh which will be purchased in the suffering of Americans, but I will have the last, bitter, laugh.

Progressives need to learn how to analyze policy.  The reason you elect a particular party, Senator, President or Representative, let alone a Congress, is to implement good policies, not to pass something bad for the sake of saying they passed something.

When you pass good policy (say a stimulus bill which actually improves the job situation, instead of a stimulus bill to weak to do more than slow the bleeding) the population, aka: voters, receive good results. That makes voters happy. When they’re happy, they vote for you again.  When they aren’t happy, they don’t.  This is how LIBERAL government works.  Do good things, reap the benefits.

Reactionary government figures that if you give enough money to private interests and throw a few scraps to the population, you can buy the election.  But it doesn’t work.  Democrats received more money from special interests last election not because special interests decided they loved Democrats, but because the Republican brand was so sullied they knew the Republicans were toast.  So they gave money to the Democrats to protect their interests.  They bought in.

But the second Democrats are weakened, and Republicans look like they can win, they’ll go back to giving Republicans most of their money.

The right thing to do, passing good policy, isn’t just the right thing to do morally, it’s the right thing to do pragmatically.  It is clearly pointless to expect most Democratic legislators to do the right thing for moral reasons, but it would be nice if they understood they are cutting their own throats by continuously passing bad policy.

Yes, Health “Reform” is a Clusterf*** and those pushing for it are being taken

Digby gets it, noting that many middle class folks are going to be forced to spend 1/3 to a half of their disposable income to buy insurance.  This is something Dave Johnson and I have been screaming about for months.

I don’t care whether there’s a lousy, weak public option.  Even if there is (and even the House bill’s public option is weak, 12 million people will not provide sufficient market power to lower costs significantly) health care reform as currently suggested is profoundly stupid and venal.  It is a regressive tax on ordinary Americans which is funneled to private industry.  People are going to be forced to buy insurance they really cannot afford.

Digby is right to be worried about the backlash.  I wouldn’t want to have to defend this to someone whose discretionary income got slashed by a half or a third.  Who is worried about eating or paying tuition for their kids because they have so much less money. Or 20-somethings out of university, crushed by huge student loans, also being forced to buy insurance they can’t afford and realizing that means they’ll never, ever, be able to afford a house.

The people who are pushing a lousy public option as if it will fix the problems innate in an individual mandate system are welcome to take the “credit” for doing so.  Because this is insanity.  Absolute insanity.  And everyone pushing for it, whether they call themselves progressives or not, is aiding and abetting this insanity and will be bear responsibility for the backlash.

And there will be backlash.

Pakistan Army assault on Warziristan Taliban forces begins

Apparently we’re looking at three columns of troops, about 30K in number, with air and artillery support against somewhere between 10 to 25K Taliban and allied groups.  The army has said that they figure everyone in the area is Taliban or supporters since everyone else should have left, but al-Jazeera is noting that the population is about 500K, and only 150K or so have left.

The obvious model for the Taliban to use is the Hezbollah model, so successful against the Israelis during the last Israeli attack on Lebanon.  However Pakistan forces are a lot more willing to take losses than Israelis, and I can’t imagine the Taliban have the discipline, iron-clad secrecy,  and technical chops of Hezbollah.  Let alone years to build up a bunker/comm/tunnel network.

That said, if I were the Taliban and I’d decided to fight, certainly I would be trying to copy Hezbollah.  Heavy heavy dig in, well camouflaged.  They have to blunt the enemy’s air power, channel them into killing fields, and make it into a morale battle (the one place where they had better have an advantage, if they hope to have a chance in hell of winning.)

The army stating they consider everyone remaining a Talib or a supporter means they don’t intend to let the Taliban go to ground in the population—they’ll kill civilians if necessary.

Isolate – concentrate – annihilate.  The anti-guerrilla playbook.

We’ll see if the Taliban is playing by that book.

My bet is on the army, at least for the duration of the operation (they’ll get cut up by pinprick attacks later).  But if they lose the operation outright, it will be fascinating.

Confusion over what government does

So, what’s wrong with this thinking?  First, from the NYTimes:

The shrinking supply of these apartments, highlighted by researchers at New York University, illustrates not only the increasing strain that housing costs have had on this city of renters, but also the limits of the mayor’s success in providing the city’s poor with reasonable places to live. While the mayor’s plan has put thousands of low-income families in new or rehabilitated buildings and helped stabilize neighborhoods, it has been nearly drowned out by the twin waves of gentrification and rent deregulation.

Then, from FDL, in reference to the above:

Mayors like Bloomberg are trying to keep up, but this is clearly a bigger problem than classic development planning schemes can solve.

Deregulation is government policy.  Therefore one of the two main factors driving poor folks out of New York is fully something that could be reversed by government any time they want to.

People get awfully confused about what government does and doesn’t do, and there’s little that’s more classic development planning than rent control.  Rent control existed exactly to make sure that poorer people weren’t driven out of neighborhoods.  Removing it has had exactly the effect anyone should have expected.

The one post on Goldman Sachs you NEED to read

Seriously, go read it. Numerian explains where Goldman Sachs’ profits come from.  Hint: it isn’t from investment banking or banking of any kind, and it isn’t from traditional trading either.

Numerian is the financial and econoblogger whom almost no one reads, whom everyone should read.  He gets almost everything right, long in advance, he understand the intricacies of financial markets extraordinarily well, and he’s good at explaining what he knows so ordinary people can understand it.

Read.

Perhaps record bonuses and no new lending is what Obama wanted

Goldman Sachs is due to pay record bonuses, and the financial sector as a whole is likely to do the same.  Meanwhile, new mortgages and refinanced mortgages, as well as business lending is dead in the water.  If it isn’t government underwritten, or a credit card, forget it.

While I can’t say I predicted record bonuses this year, I and many others did predict that the bailouts wouldn’t get lending going again, because it was better for banks to keep the money on hand for buyouts and leveraged games, and many of them truly are massively impaired.

In other words, that the bailouts wouldn’t do what they were sold as doing—increase lending, was predicted.  Repeatedly.

Not much we can do when the people in charge don’t listen to those with track records, and deliberately hire those whose track records suck.

Well suck at helping ordinary people.  The people hired or retained by Obama  to run the US economy have amazing track records helping executives get paid obscenely, making sure large banks make fake profits and bailing out executives whose greed causes disasters.

Perhaps Obama hired for what he wanted, and his hires are executing policies that accomplish what Obama wants?

Take your pick.  Either Obama is an incompetent or his policies are accomplishing what he wants them to.

Central Banks put 63% of New Money into Euros and Yen

Ouch:

Over the last three months, banks put 63 percent of their new cash into euros and yen — not the greenbacks — a nearly complete reversal of the dollar’s onetime dominance for reserves, according to Barclays Capital. The dollar’s share of new cash in the central banks was down to 37 percent — compared with two-thirds a decade ago.

Currently, dollars account for about 62 percent of the currency reserve at central banks — the lowest on record, said the International Monetary Fund.

Let me repeat.  Paulson/Geithner/Obama/Bernanke DID NOT fix the financial crisis, they just threw money at it without fixing the underlying problems. Patting themselves on the back for saving the US is entirely premature.

Yes Virginia, Americans are fat as a group

Chicago Dyke has started a conversation about food and obesity in America which led to some amusing denial (though there are some legitimate methodological issues with how overweight is defined.)

But no foreigner who travels to the US has any doubt that Americans are, as a group, fat. I notice it the second I get on an airplane traveling to the US, and I notice it for the trip, and I really notice it when I get home and go on the subway, and the average person is so much thinner. It’s brutal.

Too much of the wrong type of food, not enough exercise. I first noticed it when I traveled to Boston in 05. I was on a corporate account and we ate out every night, and the plate sizes were huge. At first I choked it all down (raised in one of those “clean your plate” households) eventually I just stopped eating it all.

Less, better quality food is far healthier.  But less better quality food costs more and restaurants and supermarkets both charge more if you want to eat well.

The rise of suburbs and the car has also left much of the country walking unfriendly, and most Americans get essentially no exercise.

(International airlines put aside more weight for Americans than other nationalities, btw.)

I think a large reason Americans let themselves be abused by their elites is that they are fat and heavily medicated. The number of Americans on anti-depressants (a drug class which is more addictive than opiates, btw) is staggering. You’re drugged to the gills so that you will put up with the way you’re absued rather than taking to the streets.

Being unhappy when your life is shit is natural folks. Drugging yourself to make yourself tolerate is a palliative, not a cure.

And a lot of these drugs also lead to weight gain. Bonus.

Notice that your elites as a group (there are exceptions, like Summers) are not fat.  In fact, they are exercise fanatics who watch what they eat very carefully.  Between that and actually getting good health care, they live and work into their seventies.

But fat drugged unhealthy Americans are easier to control, so what they do for themselves, they sure as hell don’t do for you.

Page 511 of 532

Powered by WordPress & Theme by Anders Norén