
Edit: oops. I’m full of it. Misread the poll. In fact it indicates the opposite of my title. Ignore the below. Perhaps the public option will be fantastically popular.
The problem with public option polling is that the questions imply strongly that everyone has access to it. In fact, most people don’t have access to it (if, for example, your employer offers insurance you can’t opt out and go to the public option.) Kip Sullivan did a bit of investigating and found a poll which actually did inform Americans of this fact (h/t Corrente):
“Would you support or oppose having the government create a new health insurance plan to compete with private health insurance plans?”
Support: 55%
Oppose:42%
Unsure: 3%If oppose/unsure: “What if this government-sponsored plan was available only to people who cannot get health insurance from a private insurer? In that case, would you support or oppose it?”
Support: 21%
Oppose: 24%
That’s quite the difference, don’t you think? As I noted in my last post, voters are going to be furious with Democrats if they pass any of the current proposed health care “reform” bills. The public option in all of them is crippled and the subsidies are low, such that they will eat as much as 1/3 to a half of many people’s disposable income.
Because the public option proposed in any of these bills is not robust, since they won’t have enough enrollment to have market pricing power, and thus won’t be able to force down costs, there is no reason to believe that health care reform will actually contain health cost increases below inflation, let alone below wage increases.
Since the bills also force people to buy insurance, that means voters will be forced to buy insurance whose cost will rise faster than their wages. This is particular pernicious when it comes to 20 and 30-somethings, fresh out of College, with huge student loans already, and few good job prospects.
This is horrible policy. It is also political suicide. The people in the progressive blogosphere who are pushing for a “public option” without insisting on an actual robust option (again, none of the options being considered are robust and even if linked to Medicare rates none of them will be because they are not large enough) are pushing for a law which is a massive giveaway to insurance companies—a regressive tax on the middle class. It is worse than immoral, though it’s terribly immoral, it is a horrible mistake the price for which will be paid at the ballot box.
I have warned on this repeatedly, as have others. We have not been listened to. I am not looking forward to having the last laugh on this, because it is a laugh which will be purchased in the suffering of Americans, but I will have the last, bitter, laugh.
Progressives need to learn how to analyze policy. The reason you elect a particular party, Senator, President or Representative, let alone a Congress, is to implement good policies, not to pass something bad for the sake of saying they passed something.
When you pass good policy (say a stimulus bill which actually improves the job situation, instead of a stimulus bill to weak to do more than slow the bleeding) the population, aka: voters, receive good results. That makes voters happy. When they’re happy, they vote for you again. When they aren’t happy, they don’t. This is how LIBERAL government works. Do good things, reap the benefits.
Reactionary government figures that if you give enough money to private interests and throw a few scraps to the population, you can buy the election. But it doesn’t work. Democrats received more money from special interests last election not because special interests decided they loved Democrats, but because the Republican brand was so sullied they knew the Republicans were toast. So they gave money to the Democrats to protect their interests. They bought in.
But the second Democrats are weakened, and Republicans look like they can win, they’ll go back to giving Republicans most of their money.
The right thing to do, passing good policy, isn’t just the right thing to do morally, it’s the right thing to do pragmatically. It is clearly pointless to expect most Democratic legislators to do the right thing for moral reasons, but it would be nice if they understood they are cutting their own throats by continuously passing bad policy.