hopefully Santa has been kind to you, and Christmas has been and is a happy time for you.
Jane Hamsher connects the dots over at FDL. The NYTimes has reported:
Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, which buy and resell mortgages, have used $112 billion — including $15 billion for Fannie in November — of a total $400 billion pledge from the Treasury. Now, according to people close to the talks, officials are discussing the possibility of increasing that commitment, possibly to $400 billion for each company, by year-end, after which the Treasury would need Congressional approval to extend it.
Now, on the face of it, this makes no sense whatsoever. They’ve only spent $112 billion of 400 billion and they need another 400 billion? There two most likely possibilities, which aren’t mutually exclusive are that Freddie and Fannie have a ton of bad crap on the books that they haven’t acknowledged yet. I have always believed that their losses would be much higher than originally acknowledged. The second is what Jane suggests, and which I think must be part of the picture:
The White House knows it can’t get approval for more TARP money through Congress, so the administration is going to double the commitment to Fannie and Freddie from $400 billion to $800 billion, and then they can use the money to buy up more toxic assets from the banks
Jane also points out that due to a bill Rahm authored, there is no inspector for Freddie and Fannie.
Because there is a good chance the Fed will be audited, and because banks are still very impaired with bad debt (ie. they still need to be bailed out) Freddie and Fannie may be the only place left to store all the toxic financial wage—to take it off the banks hands. In the meantime, this is a back door extension of TARP, done this way because the administration knows that Congress would never approve it.
While I’m enjoying seeing some Progressives come out against the Senate bill, noting that it’s worse than nothing, the fact of the matter is that the House Bill wasn’t that much better. The public option in the House bill was so weak that insurance provided by it was expected to have higher premiums than private plans, and while the subsidies were more generous they weren’t so high that they wouldn’t have driven many folks into bankruptcy.
I am heartened that there was a red line that some would not cross, especially my ex-colleagues at FDL, but I am mystified because the fundamental arguments that are being used apply almost as much to the House plan as the Senate plan with a few exceptions.
At this point I don’t suppose it matters. The Senate plan is what’s going to pass, any changes to it will be minor, since Nelson and Lieberman will walk if anything major is changed and there isn’t a block of progressive Representatives with enough guts to threaten to do the same and mean it.
But I wonder if there’d been a firestorm earlier, from the left, pushing for a better House bill, if the envelope might not have been moved left enough to get a better bill. This last minute firestorm, while welcome, seems unlikely to change anything. Perhaps complaining earlier wouldn’t have either. I guess we’ll never know.
As you may be aware, Sheriff Joe, he of the infamous tent cities and constant violation of civil rights, is considering running for Arizona governor. And there’s reason to believe that if he does he’ll probably win.
My guess is that Joe Arpaio is the future of America. There is a swelling tide of right wing populism, now that Democrats have refused to allow left-wing populism any purchase. The anger is building as people on the ground see that banks and insurance companies and other fat cats are being taken care of, while ordinary people lose their jobs, their houses, and the very hope they were promised by Barack Obama.
The health care bill being passed is only going to intensify this. Most of the benefits don’t kick in till 2014, but the taxes kick in before then. The talking point of being forced to buy bad insurance is going to be used, over and over again.
When I was a kid, I grew up in large part in Vancouver. Vancouver at the time had a lot of Chinese and a huge influx of Sikhs, yet there was very little racism. I commented on that to my Dad once, a man who had grown up in the Great Depression and who had lived and worked all over the world, including in the southern US in the 50s, and his response is one I’ve always remembered.
“Things are fine now, because there are enough jobs. As soon as things get bad, you just watch how racism and hatred flare up.”
When people are down, they can either come together in shared hope and work for a better future, or they can fragment into identity groups, looking for scapegoats for what’s wrong with their world. Sherrif Joe offers the boot: the sense of a strong man enforcing the laws and making bad people pay—bad people who aren’t like you.
He offers simple solutions to hard problems. His solutions won’t work, but they offer certainty and a sense of direction when people have none.
So do other right wing populist canards like tort reform (everyone hates lawyers) and a flat tax (who likes trying to figure out their tax form) and fighting terrorists. They don’t work. They won’t work. But no one is offering the sort of left wing populism that will work, and the only other thing on offer right now is a Democratic party which seems to bail out every corporation in the land, while ignoring citizens.
So America’s going to get a right wing populist backlash. The Tea Parties, which left-wingers were laughing at 6 months ago, are now as popular or more popular than either of the major political parties.
Populist rage is one of those forces you either harness or get flattened by. Looks like “flattened by” is what Democrats have chosen. Unfortunate for them, and even more unfortunate for America, because the Tea Party’s solutions not only won’t work, they’ll make things worse.
But, as Churchill once said, “Americans always do the right thing, after doing all the wrong things first”.
I guess we’ve got another cycle of wrong things to go. I wonder if, after that, America will be strong enough for any of the right things to work.
Note: edited to reflect that Sherrif Joe isn’t running yet, just considering it, though polls show that if he runs he will probably win. Mea culpa.
Seriously, someone explain to me what is wrong with Cadillac plans. Yes, they cost more. That’s because they’re the only plans where you stand a chance of actually getting the care you really need, when you need it, and not going bankrupt. We should want more of them, but that can’t be done because we can’t afford it.
Unless, of course, the US went to something rational—like, say, Medicare-for-all, instead of trying to reinvent the wheel. Why? Because Medicare-for-all would cut health care costs by at least a third.
The health care crisis isn’t about people not having insurance, it’s about people not getting the health care they need when they need it without having to pay money they can’t afford. When I go to a Canadian hospital, I never, ever, even see a bill.
And unless you’re a multi-millionaire, I get better care than you get too.