Ian Welsh

The horizon is not so far as we can see, but as far as we can imagine

No the rich aren’t like you

It’s quite noticeable that the conservative rich massively outspend their more liberal brethren when it comes to influencing politics.  I’ve seen estimates as high as a 9/1 difference in outside spending for Republicans vs. Democrats.  Part of this is because Obama isn’t a liberal (and so, Soros, for example, is refusing to help this election) but this is an issue that transcends elections.  Conservative rich like the Koch have spent billions building conservative institutions and message machinery (Fox, Heritage, talk radio, much much more).

The argument I have heard is that liberal rich should be concerned, because they may lose the rule of law.  The rich use law much more than the poor or middle class, or even the upper class. They sue all the time, their corporations are creatures of law, and so on.  so they should want to maintain the rule of law.  What benefits everyone, benefits them too.

All true, except that they don’t think they’re losing the rule of law.  They think that the law will protect their interests, and not those of others.

Since that is already mostly their experience (the law is a bludgeon for them rather than against them more often than not, in part because only they can really afford to use it to its full extent) they don’t see any reason why they can’t tilt the field even further.

In terms of equitable law (including legislation) benefiting everyone: yes and no.  The era of lessened responsibility and of legislative and judicial capture has made them filthy rich.  Arguably they would have been as rich or nearly as rich in a functioning society which produced more equitable incomes and better GDP growth because demand wouldn’t have been strangled (income for the rich rose just fine during the 45 to 75 period) BUT in relative terms they wouldn’t be as rich or powerful, because other people would be richer.  Comparative power is what it’s about.  If America becomes a third world country and the rich live in massive compounds, flying from one to the other (like they, er, do now) and the courts rule in their favor and the legislatures write bills for thm what is the negative?  It’s only a real problem if they lose control, or the lower orders become uppity enough to go all Bastille day on them, which they don’t think Americans will do.

I’m not saying they’re necessarily right, but this is the way they think.

It is not clear to me that liberal rich see nearly as much benefit to them personally.  They half buy the conservative argument, because that is their lived experience–they don’t have to deal with ordinary people, they don’t fly on the same planes, they don’t take the subway or buses or even ordinary taxis most of the time, they live in a bubble in which the problems of normal people effect them only remotely.  They have hotels rooms or whole hotels which cost so much you and I will never enter them (we don’t even know their names, by and large) with private garages to private elevators to private lobbies to private rooms, from which they are conveyed in helicopters or limousines to private jets.  They never see someone who isn’t part of their class or a servant or retainer.  All this assuming they don’t have a private residence in every city they spend any significant amount of time in.

This is not an exaggeration. Most people have no idea how the rich really live.

They aren’t like us, there is a point where wealth becomes so huge that it lifts you out of ordinary existence and the global rich (including the American rich) are past that event horizon.

Repudiating Liberalism or Obama

We’re coming up on the midterms, and the Republicans are cruising.  Odds are very high that  they will retake the House, there is an outside chance they will retake the Senate.  This is being spun as, is being seen as, a repudiation of liberalism and progressivism.

Back in early 2009 I told others in the blogosphere that we had to come out against Obama.  And by early, I mean late January.  The reason was simple enough: having seen what he did on TARP and then seeing his stimulus bill, I knew for a fact that he wasn’t going to fix the economy.  His “negotiating” strategy, if it was that, indicated he wasn’t going to take Republicans on, and that he was either spineless or essentially a right winger, just not crazy right wing.

Given these facts, it was clear that his policies were going to be seen to fail.  Quibble all you want about the stimulus, the bottom line is that it didn’t kick the economy out of the recession (in large part due to the bail out the banks policy which TARP symbolized, even if it was not the largest part of that policy.)

If Obama was seen as liberal, and his policies then failed, liberalism would be discredited.  It must be made clear, starting as soon as possible, that he was not a liberal and that liberals and progressives repudiated him.  A few people doing it in 2010, mostly half-heartedly, when he had already been seen to fail, simply looks like rats deserting a sinking ship, as it did when conservatives in 2007 started saying Bush wasn’t actually a conservative.

I lost that argument.  Frankly, opinion leaders aren’t willing to take those risks.  They saw that Obama was popular with the base, that everyone was still in “hope without reason” mode, and even when they agreed (and some did) that his policies were a failure, that he’d betray unions, that he was going to be a disaster on civil rights, they wouldn’t do it. “The audience isn’t there yet.”

The art of opinion leadership had become “see where the mob is going, get out in front and pretend you lead them there.”

So be it.

What is done is done.  What needs to be done is this.  The liberal wing of the Democratic party must be SEEN to take out Obama.  There must be a primary challenge.  If there is not, liberalism will be discredited for at least a decade, time America cannot afford, since liberal solutions work and conservative solutions,  whether pushed by right wing Dems or Republicans, don’t.

Are you a liberal first, or a Democrat?  You can’t be both.

The Lesser Evil Argument: I’ll discuss the fear-monger “Republicans are so bad” defense of supporting Dems no matter what at greater length in a later post, for now, the short version is this: Republicans ARE going to to  win again, Dems are not going to stay in charge for 20 years.  If Dems don’t do the right things when they can, the country will still slide into ruin.  The status quo of Dems moving slightly to the right, then Republicans rocketing to the right leads America to ruin.  All “Dems at all costs” partisans are doing is making the process go on somewhat longer.  That’s fine if you’re 70, or younger and in really bad health, but if you don’t expect to die soon, all you’re doing is putting off the catastrophic meltdown of America, not doing what is necessary to stop it from occurring.)

You can generally count on Obama…

… to do the wrong thing.

The Obama administration said it plans to appeal a ruling striking down the law (DADT), and asked a federal judge for an emergency stay of her decision.

And think the reason he has problems it that folks think he’s too left wing, but his policies were all good ones

During our hour together, Obama told me he had no regrets about the broad direction of his presidency. But he did identify what he called “tactical lessons.” He let himself look too much like “the same old tax-and-spend liberal Democrat.” He realized too late that “there’s no such thing as shovel-ready projects” when it comes to public works. Perhaps he should not have proposed tax breaks as part of his stimulus and instead “let the Republicans insist on the tax cuts” so it could be seen as a bipartisan compromise.

As I’ve said before, the problem with this generation of Democratic politicians is they’re screwups and they are incapable of learning from their screwups.

Washington State May Cut Medicaid Drug Benefits

I notice that of the solutions suggested, raising taxes on the rich isn’t one of them. Truly, such a thing is unthinkable: far more unthinkable than poor people dying because they don’t have medication.

Interesting set of priorities.

I also strongly suspect that the savings will be less than the government thinks, since without medication many folks will wind up in the hospital.

Just sayin’.

Apparently Axelrod and the Administration Want a Democratic Wipeout

Seriously, when the Administration says they oppose a countrywide freeze on foreclosures only weeks before the election, it’s hard to interpret their statements any other way.

I’m guessing the calculation is that Obama’s squeeze of entitlement spending for the middle class is more likely to pass if there are more Republicans in Congress.  (ie. they are completely corrupt and utterly in the pocket of bankers who are giving more money to Republicans.)

Or they could be complete and utter morons with an out of control drug habit.  I mean anyone who says, like Axelrod did, that ““I’m hoping that with more seats, Republicans will feel a greater sense of responsibility to work WITH us” is clearly not just in denial, he is as Peter Dauo said, hallucinating.

How the Foreclosure mess would play out in an actual Republic Of Law and an actual Free Market

Here’s how this plays out in an actual free market society which follows the law (ie., not this one.)

You go through and figure out if you can prove title to the property. If you can’t, those who were insured go to the title insurance companies.  A huge legal battle ensures, with the title insurance companies claiming that they were the victims of fraud from their clients, the banks.  Eventually, the title insurance companies pay out whatever they have to pay out that they can pay out, and most of them probably go bankrupt.

The banks then go bankrupt, which, well, they already are anyway, so maybe we should stop pretending.

The title insurance companies did not do their due diligence.  They deserve to be destroyed for not doing their jobs.  The banks engaged in and colluded with systemic fraud, they deserve to go out of business and their executives should go to jail.

And no, the real economy does not take it too hard on the chin.  You wipe out a ton of debts, those people are no longer underwater and can buy.  The banks are taken over by the FDIC, the shareholders are wiped out and the bondholders take a bath.  The Fed refloats the banks (after breaking them up) and they go back to lending the way they should have.  It costs LESS in the long run to do this than it does to keep extending and pretending, and non-zombie banks can actually lend.

Yes, the investor class takes it on the chin and this includes some widows and orphans, and that’s bad (throw in some undoing of “welfare reform” if you feel bad for them. Not that “slash food stamps” Obama is likely to.)  But it’s better than eternal zombie banks and illegal foreclosures up the wazoo.  And the investor class is essentially worthless anyway, they have spent the last 30 years investing in asset bubbles and offshoring industries and jobs, not in the useful productive domestic economy.  Letting them take their losses (and these are their losses) is a good thing, and is the free market thing to do.

It also wipes out a class of people who are driving the buying of politics, and who tend to prefer Republicans, if you want to do some crass political calculation.  Which, frankly, would be nice, since apparently Dems crass political calculations are done with an abacus they don’t know how to work.

Addendum: a friend sends me this suggested course of action by Karl Dennniger, which I think is a good one.  Odds of being pursued?  Minimal.  But we can hope.  As Denninger points out, if private interests steal the homes of millions of citizens with the collusion of government, well, that doesn’t lead anywhere pretty.

Objectively worse off under Obama

I keep hearing people saying that Hispanics are angry with Democrats because comprehensive immigration reform hasn’t been pushed.

That’s part of it, but in suggesting that Democrats sins are passive, it is effectively a lie.  Under Obama deportations have actually increased, and this is entirely an administrative matter, which he could change himself without Congress’s approval.


I would add that the same is true of womens ability to get an abortion.  Objectively worse than under Bush.  For two major Democratic constituencies, Obama has not just failed to make things better, he has made them worse.

Meanwhile police refuse to pursue criminal charges against banks breaking into housing to change locks when they don’t have clear title to the property.   Many people have lost their houses based on fraudulent paperwork submitted by law firms and banks, where the banks committed perjury about their title to property.

Virtually all of this is interstate commerce and falls under RICO statutes if you want it to.  The DOJ could go after it tomorrow if Obama wanted to.  He doesn’t.

One can only assume, since he has the power to put the fear of God into banksters and refuses to do so, that Obama approves of what they’re doing.

Obama is not a liberal.   He is objectively making things worse for many Americans, including the most vulnerable and core constituencies of the Democratic party.

Republic of Men Rather Than Laws

A friend of mine notes the wave of fraudulent foreclosures, foreclosures where firms simply faked the paperwork needed to prove they have standing to foreclose (that they actually own the mortgage.)  There have been some moves to stem the fraud, not the least of which is by Florida’s Attorney General Bill McCollum, but those who appear to be the worst offenders are firing back, going after him and other judges who have thrown out cases.

This is a logical consequence of refusing to go after banksters for fraud. The fraud was so systemic (the majority of CDOs based on housing) that virtually every major executive was involved.  The DOJ and others chose not to prosecute criminally, and as a result the message was sent that the executive class, as a group, will not be prosecuted for fraud.

So, of course, they doubled down.

This is illness creep from the refusal to go after Bush era crimes.  Political elites made themselves immune from prosecution for any crime that a lot of them are involved in, then corporate elites.

America isn’t a nation of laws, it is a nation of men. Has been since at least 2007, when Nancy made her choice not to go after wrongdoers.  Obama confirmed this in 2009, when he refused to use the DOJ to go after either Bush era crimes or really go after mortgage and security fraud.

I hope it can be firebreaked here.  Maybe it can.  But when you exempt entire classes of important people from the law, every other group of important people sees no reason why they should be subject to it either.

If it is to be firebreaked here it must be done with criminal prosecution.  Corporate elites won’t be deterred by fines, they consider them only a cost of doing business.

(Oh, and the next step if it isn’t firebreaked?  Deficiency judgements: going after people for the amount that’s underwater.)

Page 477 of 532

Powered by WordPress & Theme by Anders Norén