One of the signature features of the last fifty years or so is the fragmentation of indetity into many different pieces: ethenicity, gender, sexual preference, disability, with a sort of oppression Olympics. Being a black women with a disability means you’re super oppressed.
And that’s true. No question.
But what neoliberal identity politics (IP) did was fragment coalitions. The first rule of coalitions is “no separate peace” — even if you get what you want, you keep fighting for the rest of the coalition to get what it needs. But modern IP inculcates resentment of other groups: we’re oppressed and they’re evil. Worse, the dogma was that if you were white you were always racist (no redemption) and always would be. If male you’d always be misogynist, you can’t help yourself. And so on.
There was an insistence that people were bad, would always be bad, and at most they should shut up and support oppressed minorities but even so they’d always be bad people.
This ran straight into lived experience. The first group to start seeing a sustained decline in standards of living was working class males, white males. They peaked in 1968. That’s fifty-eight years ago. Fifty eight. That’s a long time to see things get worse.
At the same time things were getting better for women. Yes, they still learn less than a man in most cases, BUT what matters is not absolute numbers, but direction of movement. It’s that direction which determines if people feel good or bad about their circumstances.
We’re about 3 weeks into our annual fundraiser. We’ve raised about $10,145 out of a $14,500 goal from 8 people. This blog is free for everyone to read, and we’ve got about ten thousand visitors a month. Of those about 6K are regulars.
The simplest truth of capitalism is that you get more of what you pay for. Money sends the message and resources required to do things. In most cases your power is tiny, one of millions, but this isn’t like that because the numbers and the need (to keep the blog and Ian running) are relatively small.
So if you value this blog, if it’s worth having around to you, please consider Subscribing or Donating.
What IP did was give increased representation to minority groups at the same time as the average person was being immiserated to benefit the rich.
Identity was used as a tool to shatter solidarity between people, by dividing them into competing groups. The problem, it was posited, was all white men, or all whites, or white women vs. minority women. Identity was atomized and turned against people who weren’t doing that well.
This was GREAT if you were a member of the elite who benefited from neoliberal policies which transferred vast amounts of wealth and income upwards: the hoi polloi were fighting each other instead of fighting you: they were competing over scraps while the elite hoovered up vast amounts of money.
What elites want more than anything else is for their “lessers” to compete against each other instead of against those who actually took the wealth, power and money for themselves. Divide and conquer is domestic as well as foreign policy.
It’s hard for commoners to hold elites to account, because elites are small organized groups who are able to act for their shared class interests much easier than millions of disorganized people.
And the tragedy is that many of the people pushing identity politics thought they were doing good: they were sincere and trying to help. Alas, the end effect was to hasten the shattering of the ability for working people (this includes most of the middle class) to get their share of the pie.
Of course there was more to it than this, like the deliberate breaking of unions, and the massive surge of incarceration, but identity politics was part of the division and conquest of the commons.
We need an ideology for the masses which respect the law of alliances. Again, no separate peace. No quitting till everyone gets what they need, and no stopping until the power of our enemies, the rich and powerful, is broken.
To win, we must be as relentless as our enemies, but unlike our enemies we must fight for everyone except our oppressors. Everyone should have a good life. Everyone should have a fair share of what society produces. At the end, we only have each other, and if we don’t have that, if we insist on fighting each other as fragmented identity groups, all we do is empower our greatest enemies: our own leaders.
Think of commoners as dogs at a noble’s table, fighting over scraps thrown on the floor while the nobles feast.
Leave a Reply