The horizon is not so far as we can see, but as far as we can imagine

Week-end Wrap – Political Economy – September 25, 2022

by Tony Wikrent

The Making Of “LINCOLN” Behind The Scenes

[TW: A enthralling discussion of how they strove to make the film as authentic as possible. The clock ticking heard in the background of some scenes, for example, was a recording made of a watch Lincoln had actually owned. And Daniel Day Lewis describing how he researched and came to love Lincoln as a person is simply marvelous.]


Light Under a Bushel: Eric Foner, interviewed by Nawal Arjini

[The New York Review of Books, September 17, 2022]

My father, Jack Foner, lost his job at the City University of New York because of the legislative investigation of “Communist influence” on the school. This was in the early 1940s, before McCarthy. My mother, who was a high school art teacher and an artist in her own right, was also named and was going to be fired from the city educational system, but the principal of her school allowed her to retire on a medical disability instead so that she could get a pension. My family lived on my mother’s pension while I was growing up. Much later, in the late 1960s, my father was able to get a teaching job for the remainder of his career.

Blacklisting had a devastating impact on the teaching of history. Some of the very best scholars were thrown out of the profession. But I eventually realized that that experience was very educational. I learned something a lot of my college classmates didn’t know and had to learn during the 1960s: the rhetoric of freedom, liberty, and progress in our country does not comport with reality. A person losing his livelihood because someone called him a Communist—what does that tell us about freedom of speech, academic freedom in this country? The principles the country claimed to stand for and the practices it instituted were contradictory, which many young people came to discover in other ways, through the Vietnam War and the way the government lied or the civil rights revolution and the idea that we lived in equality….

“We can’t accept the principle that the way to judge a course of study is by how much money you will make. It’s important to study history if you want to be an intelligent citizen in a democracy…


The Complicity of the Textbooks

Eric Foner [The New York Review of Books, September 22, 2022]

In Teaching White Supremacy, Donald Yacovone traces how the writing of American history, from Reconstruction on, has falsified and illuminated our racial past…..

Like most works of history, W.E.B. Du Bois’s Black Reconstruction in America concludes with a bibliography listing primary and other sources consulted by the author. Most of the groupings are unexceptional—for example, monographs, government reports, and biographies. But Du Bois’s first and largest category comes as a shock to the modern reader: it consists of books by historians who believe African Americans to be “sub-human and congenitally unfitted for citizenship and the suffrage.” Just before the bibliography, Du Bois includes a chapter, “The Propaganda of History,” that indicts the profession for abandoning scholarly objectivity in the service of “that bizarre doctrine of race that makes most men inferior to the few.” This was the state of historical scholarship in the United States when Black Reconstruction was published, in 1935.


US is becoming a ‘developing country’ on global rankings that measure democracy, inequality 

[The Conversation, via Naked Capitalism 9-21-2022]

In its global rankings, the United Nations Office of Sustainable Development dropped the U.S. to 41st worldwide, down from its previous ranking of 32nd. Under this methodology – an expansive model of 17 categories, or “goals,” many of them focused on the environment and equity – the U.S. ranks between Cuba and Bulgaria. Both are widely regarded as developing countries.

The U.S. is also now considered a “flawed democracy,” according to The Economist’s democracy index.

As a political historian who studies U.S. institutional development, I recognize these dismal ratings as the inevitable result of two problems. Racism has cheated many Americans out of the health care, education, economic security and environment they deserve. At the same time, as threats to democracy become more serious, a devotion to “American exceptionalism” keeps the country from candid appraisals and course corrections.


NYS Attorney General Documents a Decade of “Staggering” Fraud by Donald Trump, the Man Allowed to Run the U.S. Government from 2017 to 2020

Pam Martens and Russ Martens, September 22, 2022 [Wall Street on Parade]

A sampling of the more than 200 instances of fraud alleged by the New York State Attorney General is as follows:

“Relying on objectively false numbers to calculate property values. For example, Mr. Trump’s own triplex apartment in Trump Tower was valued as being 30,000 square feet when it was 10,996 square feet. As a result, in 2015 the apartment was valued at $327 million in total, or $29,738 per square foot. That price was absurd given the fact that at that point only one apartment in New York City had ever sold for even $100 million, at a price per square foot of less than $10,000. And that sale was in a newly built, ultra-tall tower. In 30 year-old Trump Tower, the record sale as of 2015 was a mere $16.5 million at a price of less than $4,500 per square foot.

“In the 2012 Statement, rent stabilized apartments at Trump Park Avenue were valued as if they were unrestricted, leading to a nearly $50 million valuation for those units—but an appraisal accounting for those units’ stabilized [rent] status valued them collectively at just $750,000;

“The Mar-a-Lago club was valued as high as $739 million based on the false premise that it was unrestricted property and could be developed and sold for residential use, even though Mr. Trump himself signed deeds donating his residential development rights and sharply restricting changes to the property – in reality, the club generated annual revenues of less than $25 million and should have been valued at closer to $75 million…

“Increasing the value of golf clubs to incorporate a ‘brand premium’ despite expressly advising in the Statements that brand value was not included in the figures and despite GAAP rules prohibiting inclusion of internally-generated intangible brand premiums. For example, in the 2013 Statement, the value of Mr. Trump’s golf course in Jupiter, Florida was further inflated by fraudulently adding 30% for the Trump ‘brand.’ Combining the inflation from using the fixed-asset approach with the 30% brand premium, Mr. Trump claimed that a club he purchased for $5 million in 2012 was worth more than $62 million in 2013. The 2013 Statement included the same fraudulent 30% brand premium for six other golf clubs.”


The carnage of mainstream neoliberal economics

[Twitter, via Naked Capitalism Water Cooler 9-22-2022]


The Odds of a Bad Outcome are Rising 

[The Lens, via Naked Capitalism 9-19-2022] BP 9-21

This is an important piece on the US response to inflation that shows you have to ignore all the historical evidence to believe raising rates will solve the problem without pushing the cost onto working people.


The epidemic

“To boost or not to boost”

Eric Topol [Ground Truths, via Naked Capitalism Water Cooler 9-19-2022]

“The reluctance for Americans to get a booster shot has been striking. The United States currently ranks 73rd among countries for its uptake of boosters at 33% of its population. All peer, rich countries around the world are at least double that rate. Countries ranking above the US now include Rwanda, Uzbekistan, Iran, Honduras, and Azerbaijan. Seemingly, you’d have to work very hard to show up this poorly as the country that first validated the vaccines, manufactures them, and has had such a surfeit supply that it has >50 million shots it can’t get anyone to take. Nonetheless, it has maintained optimism and purchased 171 million new Omicron BA.5 variant bivalent shots. There are many reasons for this abject failure—a veritable booster botch—stemming back to the beginning of the US booster campaign plan in August 2021, with mass public confusion induced by a different plan announced every few days and infighting between the different governmental agencies (CDC, FDA, NIH, WH) as to the appropriate strategy. This was compounded by the very late endorsement that boosters are necessary for all adults that did not come until the end of November, even though the data from Israel and other countries were clearcut many months prior to that juncture. Delays, confusion, and poor messaging got boosters off on the wrong footing. All the anti-science, anti-vax, mis- and disinformation hasn’t helped at all, and has never been effectively countered.”


[Twitter, via Naked Capitalism Water Cooler 9-19-2022]


“Effectiveness of HEPA Filters at Removing Infectious SARS-CoV-2 from the Air”

[American Society for Epidemiology, via Naked Capitalism Water Cooler 9-22-2022]

“Air filtration simulation experiments quantitatively showed that an air cleaner equipped with a HEPA filter can continuously remove SARS-CoV-2 from the air. The capture ratios for SARS-CoV-2 in the air when the air cleaner was equipped with an antiviral-agent-coated HEPA filter were comparable to those with the conventional HEPA filter, and there was little effect on SARS-CoV-2 in the air that passed through the antiviral-reagent-coated HEPA filter.”


More Than 335,000 Lives Could Have Been Saved During Pandemic if U.S. Had Universal Health Care

[Yale School of Public Health, via The Big Picture 9-18-2022]

In the United States, death rates from COVID-19 are higher than in any other high-income country—and our fragmented and inefficient health system may be largely to blame, Yale researchers say in a new study.


Suicide by neoliberalism

Talking Energy and Inflation with Westwood Capital’s Dan Alpert — Stephanie Kelton

Stephanie Kelton [The Lens, via Mike Norman Economics 9-20-2022]

Alpert: This is the second time in 15 years that conventional thinking about oil has gotten things very wrong. The error has been compounded by the Russian invasion of Ukraine, which actually came rather late in an oil price shock that was already well underway.

Oil shocks, and energy shocks more broadly, are conventionally attributed to supply constraints (either real or artificial) or demand surges (chiefly during periods of rapid expansion, either globally or regionally). But since late 2007 the financialization of oil has led to the use of the commodity in hedging and speculation strategies not directly related to the commodity itself, but to using the dollar denominated commodity to hedge U.S. inflation and the dollar itself (Bouchouev). Accordingly, during periods in which traders fear that the Fed will be forced into highly accommodative policy (especially in the most recent round in which such policy was accompanied by unprecedented fiscal stimulus and unique, albeit temporary, supply constraints related to the pandemic) they have increasingly tended express their concern regarding the prospect for inflation resulting in dollar devaluation by going long oil futures.


JPMorgan Chase, Morgan Stanley and Wells Fargo Flunk a Test Measuring their Support for American Democracy

Pam Martens and Russ Martens, September 15, 2022 [Wall Street on Parade]

The nonpartisan watchdog group, Accountable.US, has released the results of an investigation into how committed to democracy the 100 largest corporations in America are. The corporations were graded on support for voting rights, the electoral process, and American democracy. The results were provided in an interactive resource called the American Democracy Scorecard.

Researchers looked at 14 key criteria. Seven elements of the criteria involved making pro-democracy statements, being affiliated with pro-democracy organizations, and taking other pro-democracy actions. Seven other criteria involved corporate contributions to elected officials who are undermining democracy and voting rights.

Three of the largest mega banks on Wall Street, JPMorgan Chase, Morgan Stanley, and Wells Fargo, flunked the democracy test, each receiving a score of “F.” Goldman Sachs received a “D.” Bank of America and Citigroup received a “B” grade, but, clearly, that was based on very recent history.

Both Bank of America’s Merrill Lynch brokerage unit and Citigroup (along with most other major Wall Street firms) have compelled their workers for decades to relinquish the Seventh Amendment to the U.S. Bill of Rights – the right to a jury trial – and agree to bring all legal disputes into Wall Street’s private justice system called “mandatory arbitration” as a condition of getting a job at the company. To put it simply, Wall Street, for decades, has been forcing its workers to forego a constitutional right in order to receive a paycheck. (See here and here.) For this reason alone, these Wall Street corporations should have flunked the democracy test.


The Price of Economics

Peter Radford [via Mike Norman Economics 9-20-2022]

Economists do not study economies.  They study economics.  They study their own models and other stylized facts in ever more detail and abstraction.  They have substituted technical wizardry for contemplation.  They privilege mathematics over other kinds of analysis.  And they scrupulously avoid entanglement with history which might drag them into a conversation about just how they arrived atop Mount Economics far above the plains of reality below….

One of the great ironies of economics is that it, too, acts as a guild.  It decides what economic knowledge is good and which is bad.  It selects only certain parts of its own history to create the “right” narrative.  It tells its own stories of what it wants outsiders to know.  And it defies, quite often, its own teaching by so doing.  After all, economics tells us that restraints on trade are harmful to the great fulfillment of the harmonic perfection of market efficiency.  So why are there tenured professors of economics?  Tenure is a restraint on trade.  Where are the market forces determining what economics is or is not?  Ought those professors  not step down from tenure and expose themselves to a proper market for whatever it is they are selling?  Isn’t that, then, the method we ought employ to determine the value of economics?


Central bank priorities are not the priorities of working people

Bill Mitchell [billy blog, via Mike Norman Economics 9-18-2022]

I remember a conversation I had when I was picked up hitch hiking to Melbourne from where I was living down the coast. It was during the 1970s inflationary period, which had morphed into stagflation as a result of deliberate government policy to create unemployment and discipline the wage-price spiral. The driver was a manual worker and during a conversation about the state of the economy (I was studying economics at the time) he said “the government should care about employment because at least then everyone has a job even if prices are rising”. That conversation stuck with me because it summed up what research shows in more sophisticated ways – the costs of inflation are minimal when compared to the devastating costs of unemployment. At present, our policy makers are unwilling to recognise that reality because it is not them that bear the costs.


“Nothing will fundamentally change”

Insurers force change on police departments long resistant to it 

[Washington Post, via The Big Picture 9-18-2022]

The high cost of settlements over police misconduct has led insurers to demand police departments overhaul tactics or forgo coverage.

This is plutocracy, not capitalism

Corruption Caught On Tape 

Andrew Perez, September 23, 2022 [The Lever]

During a televised hearing, a Wall Street-friendly GOP lawmaker thanked a bank CEO for hiring his top aide.


ELECTION INSIDER: Who’s Buying The Midterms? 

Aditi Ramaswami, September 19, 2022 [The Lever]

In just five minutes, we’ll tell you what you need to know about the biggest political donors this election season.


Climate and environmental crises

Rhine Water Levels in Germany Approaching Normal Depths 

[Maritime Logistics Professional, via Naked Capitalism 9-20-2022]


The Sinaloa Cartel Is Controlling Water in Drought-Stricken Mexico

[Vice, via The Big Picture 9-21-2022]

“Water is now a valuable asset for us, and as it becomes more scarce, the more we will fight to make sure we have enough,” a cartel operative told VICE World News.


Chicago’s Tap Water Contaminated With Lead, Analysis Finds

[Gizmodo, via Naked Capitalism 9-22-2022]


Shell’s Internal Emails Show Just How Cynical Oil Companies’ Emissions Promises Are

[The New Republic, via Naked Capitalism 9-21-2022]


How oil companies endlessly avoid cleanup costs 

[High Country News, via Naked Capitalism 9-21-2022]


Restoring balance to the economy

Piercing The Corporate Climate Veil

Rishika Pardikar, September 23, 2022 [The Lever]

A landmark 2021 Dutch district court ruling ordered Shell to slash emissions by almost half by 2030. Now the oil and gas company is appealing the decision, claiming the emissions target is “just not feasible — or even reasonable,” and arguing that consumers who buy its products are actually the ones responsible for the climate disaster.

But Milieudefensie, the Dutch environmental organization that spearheaded the Shell lawsuit, is ready to fight back and is even optimistic about the outcome of the appeals process. This time, the environmentalists are contemplating a radical litigation tactic: holding Shell board members personally accountable for violating human rights by furthering the climate crisis.

Both Shell’s appeal and Milieudefensie’s planned response could prove pivotal in the battle to combat climate change, since both tacks aim to put a personal spin on corporate climate malfeasance. While the fossil fuel giant wants to pin the blame on its customers, climate defenders are taking aim at the corporate shield that protects the business executives behind these disastrous decision-making processes from liability.


“Google loses EU appeal and is fined a record $4 billion”

[Axios, via Naked Capitalism Water Cooler 9-22-2022]

“Google suffered a significant loss Wednesday when a European court denied its appeal of an antitrust decision and issued a fine of 4.1 billion euro ($4.13 billion), a record penalty. Google had challenged an earlier EU ruling that said it used its Android mobile operating system to stymie rivals, but Europe’s second-highest court upheld it. The hefty fine and ruling is a win for top EU antitrust official Margrethe Vestager, who has aggressively prosecuted Big Tech companies, and could set a precedent for future European antitrust rulings covering tech giants.”

Lambert Strether asks: “Why the small fine?” [TW: Alphabet Inc. (the name Google rebranded itself under) had revenues of $257.6 billion in 2021, and net income of $76.0 billion, while using aggressive tax accounting to avoid paying almost all taxes.]

The Importance of Citizen Activism 

David Dayen, September 23, 2022 [The American Prospect]

Today on TAP: Foreclosure activist-turned-journalist Lisa Epstein’s work leads to another victory over a predatory company.


The Reinvestment Movement vs. the Bankers 

Robert Kuttner, September 22, 2022 [The American Prospect]

In March 1975, I took a job as chief investigator of the Senate Banking Committee. My boss, Sen. William Proxmire of Wisconsin, had just become chairman, and he was looking for a journalist with a financial and investigative background to fill the newly created post.

Proxmire had been the very effective chair of the Subcommittee on Consumer Affairs. He was the nemesis of the banking industry. He had successfully sponsored Truth in Lending, Fair Credit Reporting, and Equal Credit Opportunity legislation. After the 1974 election, the banking lobby did everything they could to block Proxmire, now the senior Democrat on the committee, from ascending to chair, but they failed….

THE REINVESTMENT MOVEMENT WAS SPEARHEADED by three national groups and some inspired local leaders. In Chicago, a stay-at-home mother of six named Gale Cincotta lived in the Austin neighborhood on Chicago’s West Side, a prime target of blockbusters. In the late 1960s, Cincotta, the daughter of Italian and Greek immigrants, organized the Organization for a Better Austin (OBA) to resist blockbusters and press for normal bank credit; then in 1972, she created National People’s Action on Housing, later renamed National People’s Action and finally just People’s Action.

Cincotta connected with a Saul Alinsky–trained organizer named Shel Trapp. Their strategy was classic Alinsky: Organize your neighbors, do your homework, embarrass the bad guys, work the press, and win some modest victories, which then energizes neighbors to fight for bigger victories.

With her immense blond bouffant hairdo and street-smart bravado, Cincotta was great newspaper copy for her David-and-Goliath battles. When President Ford signed the Home Mortgage Disclosure Act, it was a banner headline story in the Chicago Tribune, crediting a jubilant Cincotta.


Altercation: How the Democrats’ Economics Changed 

Eric Alterman, September 23, 2022 [The American Prospect]

Michael Tomasky on how a dissident, if realistic, assessment of the economy became mainstream.

I want to thank Eric and the Prospect for giving me some space today to tell you about my new book. It’s called The Middle Out: The Rise of Progressive Economics and a Return to Shared Prosperity and was published earlier this month by Doubleday.

What’s it about, and why is it unique? I wrote the book to tell the story of the effort over the past decade or so by hundreds of people to change, as Joe Biden sometimes likes to say, “the economic paradigm.” ….

Well, Biden didn’t coin that phrase. I didn’t coin it. It was coined by Nick Hanauer and Eric Liu back in 2011. The fact that the phrase is more than a decade old reinforces my point above—a lot of people have been thinking about these problems for a long time….

3. Economics has changed profoundly in this century. In sum, much of economics has moved from being based on theoretical modeling to being based on empirical data. And as this change has happened, economics has moved left, not because economists are leftists, but because the empirical data showed, for example, that r > g, in Thomas Piketty’s famous formulation. That is, the data show that the system is rigged for the rich in a way theoretical modeling did not. There are still, of course, plenty of conservative economists, but a younger and more diverse generation of economists is changing the profession, and those changes are seeping their way into politics.

4. Finally, here’s how the Democrats should explain all this to people. Republicans and the right are not, of course, just going to lie down and stop arguing economics. We’re in for a long battle. I think the best way for Democrats to win it is this: They need to attach their economic ideas to the ideals that Americans are taught to cherish from an early age—democracy and freedom. They should say something like: Yes, our economic policies will put more money in your pocket. But they’ll do more. They are good for democracy, because as the founders knew, a healthy democracy depends on a strong middle class. Too much economic and political power in the hands of the rich leads to oligarchy, and that’s where we’re headed if the trend of the last few decades isn’t arrested.


Creating new economic potential – science and technology

NASA’s Perseverance Rover Investigates Geologically Rich Mars Terrain

[NASA, via The Big Picture 9-20-2022]

“This juxtaposition provides us with a rich understanding of the geologic history after the crater formed and a diverse sample suite. For example, we found a sandstone that carries grains and rock fragments created far from Jezero Crater – and a mudstone that includes intriguing organic compounds.”


Information age dystopia

The Justice Department Was Dangerous Before Trump. It’s Out of Control Now and Part 2: The Justice Department Was Dangerous Before Trump. It’s Out of Control Now 

Matt Taibbi [TK News, via Naked Capitalism 9-18-2022]


What Happened to America’s Civil Libertarians? 

Matt Taibbi [TK News, via Naked Capitalism 9-20-2022]


Facebook spied on private messages of conservatives who questioned the 2020 elections and reported them to the FBI 

[OpIndia, via Naked Capitalism 9-18-2022]


‘Pretty creepy’: Agencies illegally obtained emails, voicemails and texts 

[The Saturday Paper, via Naked Capitalism 9-18-2022]


Spyware and surveillance: Threats to privacy and human rights growing, UN report warns 

[The Guardian, via Naked Capitalism 9-19-2022]


“Facebook Proven to Negatively Impact Mental Health”

[Tel Aviv University, via Naked Capitalism Water Cooler 9-22-2022]

“The study was based on data that dates back to the 2004 advent of Facebook at Harvard University, before it took the internet by storm. Facebook was initially accessible only to Harvard students who had a Harvard email address. Quickly spreading to other colleges in and outside the US, the network was made available to the general public in the US and beyond in September 2006. The researchers were able to analyze the impact of social media use by comparing colleges that had access to the platform to colleges that did not. The findings show a rise in the number of students reporting severe depression and anxiety (7% and 20% respectively). …. The study combined information from two different datasets: the specific dates on which Facebook was introduced at 775 American colleges, and the National College Health Assessment (NCHA), a survey conducted periodically at American colleges…. the methodology also considered any differences in mental health over time or across colleges that were not related to Facebook. This approach enabled conditions similar to those of a ‘natural experiment,’ which would be impossible today now that billions of people around the world use many different social networks.”


America’s Open Wound: The CIA is not your friend

Ed Snowden [Continuing Ed., via Naked Capitalism 9-21-2022]

Our glittering nation of laws observes this year two birthdays: the 70th anniversary of the National Security Agency, on which my thoughts have been recorded, and the 75th anniversary of the Central Intelligence Agency.

The CIA was founded in the wake of the 1947 National Security Act. The Act foresaw no need for the Courts and Congress to oversee a simple information-aggregation facility, and therefore subordinated it exclusively to the President, through the National Security Council he controls.

Within a year, the young agency had already slipped the leash of its intended role of intelligence collection and analysis to establish a covert operations division. Within a decade, the CIA was directing the coverage of American news organizations, overthrowing democratically elected governments (at times merely to benefit a favored corporation), establishing propaganda outfits to manipulate public sentiment, launching a long-running series of mind-control experiments on unwitting human subjects (purportedly contributing to the creation of the Unabomber), and—gaspinterfering with foreign elections. From there, it was a short hop to wiretapping journalists and compiling files on Americans who opposed its wars.

In 1963, no less than former President Harry Truman confessed that the very agency he personally signed into law had transformed into something altogether different than he intended, writing:….


Secret Documents Have Exposed the CIA’s Julian Assange Obsession 

Jacobin, via Naked Capitalism 9-21-2022]


Tracked: How colleges use AI to monitor student protests 

[Dallas Morning News, via Naked Capitalism 9-21-2022]


“Meta Sued for Skirting Apple Privacy Rules to Snoop on Users”

[Bloomberg, via Naked Capitalism Water Cooler 9-22-2022]

“Meta Platforms Inc. was sued for allegedly building a secret work-around to safeguards that Apple Inc. launched last year to protect iPhone users from having their internet activity tracked. In a proposed class-action complaint filed Wednesday in San Francisco federal court, two Facebook users accused the company of skirting Apple’s 2021 privacy rules and violating state and federal laws limiting the unauthorized collection of personal data. A similar complaint was filed in the same court last week. The suits are based on a report by data privacy researcher Felix Krause, who said that Meta’s Facebook and Instagram apps for Apple’s iOS inject JavaScript code onto websites visited by users. Krause said the code allowed the apps to track ‘anything you do on any website,’ including typing passwords.” • Those crooks just can’t help themselves, can they?


The U.S. Government’s Vast New Privatized Censorship Regime 

[The Tablet, via Naked Capitalism 9-22-2022]


Conservative / Libertarian Drive to Civil War

A Fossil Fuels Giant Has Been Raising the Election Chances of Extreme-Right Candidates — Using a Dangerous High-Tech Weapon 

Pam Martens and Russ Martens, September 19, 2022 [Wall Street on Parade]



Open Thread


How Peace In Ukraine Has Been Made Almost Impossible


  1. bruce wilder

    I am not so sure that the cant critique of “American Exceptionalism” from the perspective of Successor Ideology is not deliberately subverting any hope of reform or recovery from America’s descent into poverty and terminal corruption, economic and political. Historically the rhetoric of American Exceptionalism was flattering the national ego with mythic falsehoods spread over blemishes like pancake makeup on an aging actor, but it was also at least a hypocritical tribute to true virtue and a hope of doing better based on a patriotism devoted at least in theory to ideals of national behavior.

    Disposing of exceptionalism is going to help the cause of reform how exactly? Realism about what strengthens the case for collective national effort to defend the Republic? Are we suppose to gaze at the Lincoln Memorial and laugh our selves silly?

    I see the trail of argument leading into ugly falsehoods I do not much like: it has become conventional wisdom for example to scorn the New Deal for its supposed racism. False claims are made that various programs did not benefit blacks. Where should I think that is going?

    I cannot help but think the real agenda for some is to paralyze or subvert political reform. (And that is the agenda that is succeeding, pushed and pulled in tandem by mindless partisanship.)

  2. DMC

    Reform, of the incremental sort historically associated with Democrats, is simply too little too late. We’ve let things go to the point where “the curtains are now on fire” and only radical action is going to prevent cascading system failure. We’ve knocked out too many of the blocks and the pyramid is going to collapse. What put the hook in it for me was the global reports of 75% population declines across a wide spectrum of insects. The knock on effects of that are HUGE and its only one indicator. As Tony notes, the US is rapidly sinking into 3rd world status, with an opulent few in control of a vast number of the peasantry. The plutocrats are not about to let themselves be ”Reformed” out of existence. That’s going to take radical if not revolutionary action, as is addressing climate change, especially related to potable water and clean energy. We simply don’t have the luxury of half-assing the job, such as we have done, heretofore. The effects are already here and we’re still arguing if they’re real, thanks to non-stop obfuscation on the part of the principal culprits.

  3. VietnamVet

    History is taught by the winners. But, like most things, it has to reflect reality, or it crashes into extremism. There are practical necessary things that are needed for life; air, water, food and shelter. These might be called secular causes. Things provided by good government. But since the Oligarch’s counter revolt, to avoid dealing with reality, the USA has gone off into aggressive exploitation and identity politics. But the looting is at the point of no return. The stock market is tumbling.

    By November we shall see if the White House is grounded in reality. Most likely not. It will challenge the Kremlin by continuing the Ukraine counteroffensive and we shall see if the Russians do what they say they will do — defend Russian territory “the four regions of Donbas” with tactical nuclear weapons.

    Italy is projected to elect a “far” right wing government. This will escalate in the cold and dark. The EU will splinter apart before Spring.

    Western civilization swings in the wind. An Armistice and an East West DMZ will bring peace and piped natural gas at a price.

  4. Willy

    “American exceptionalism” keeps the country from candid appraisals and course corrections.

    I once saw a flip house where the buyers were oblivious to the dangerous wiring, sewage smell due to lack of plumbing vents, and the badly compromised structure which could be felt but not seen. And practically anything else that could be done wrong was done wrong, because doing it right meant taking the time which would cut into profits. But it was a beautiful house in a beautiful location and I’m sure their realtor (from an “exclusive” company) subtly persuaded them to forego inspection lest “your dream home be snapped up by somebody else”. I wound up being the bad guy for delivering the bad news some years after they’d moved in.

    This is modern America and “leftism”, in a nutshell. Why do leftists have to keep staring at all the problems, when Billionaires Row and Elon’s Starships are so beautiful? Aren’t they just being jealous? Plus wasn’t Josef Mengele a progressive?

    I once knew a realtor who operated independently. His own little brokerage was dedicated to honestly educating his clients about the actual realities of their potential dream homes, good or bad. He railed against a certain home realty corporation which had gained its success using two marketing techniques: naming itself after a wealthy local neighborhood and use of the term “exclusive” even when selling little hovels. He was able to retire but not necessarily wealthy, while that suspicious corporation now dominates the home sales business in the west.

    My point is that simple memes are very powerful for the masses. Far more powerful than gaining a reputation for being honestly educators. Maybe we need a solution for this little glitch in human thinking.

  5. different clue

    “American Exceptionalism” is used by the Conservanons to condemn and prevent any useful reform. For example, people are encouraged to reject the concept of Single Payer CanadaCare for every American because that would be doing something that another country does and would therefor violate American Exceptionalism.

    The way to replace American Exceptionalism would be with attracting enough people to something better that they decide to support that concept instead for their own and their country’s greater benefit. What might that something be?

    I suggest American Okayness Ordinarianism. Make America an okay place to live for the people who live here. MAOKA. Make America O K Again. That could even be put on a red hat. The Trump gang would of course sue, which would increase publicity and sales for MAOKA red hats.

    I! am an American Okayness Ordinarian. We’re number whatever. America Okay!

Powered by WordPress & Theme by Anders Norén